Music Blogs

These Lips Were Made For Synching

Posted Fri Mar 6, 2009 4:57pm PST by Blender Magazine in The Blender Burner

You will be shocked--shocked!--to learn that some people who caught the launch of Britney Spears's Circus Tour in New Orleans thought that the comeback queen was lip-synching. Lip-synching? In a highly produced pop spectacle which involves insane dance moves, midgets, and mimes? This is not possible! It's like saying the stock market is a smoke-and-mirrors game that makes rich people richer and is so tenuous that 14 years of 401K gains can be wiped out in the blink of a eye...OK, sorry, we didn't mean to bum you out by talking about anything serious or important. Let's get back to pop stars lip-synching.

Why are people so upset by the idea of Britney lip-synching? Maybe because she didn't even indulge the illusion of live vocals with the usual "Hi ya'all! What's up? So good to be in NAME OF YOUR CITY HERE. You're the best crowd in the world" sort of chatter that goes a long way toward selling the illusion that any of the sounds you're hearing at a massive arena show are coming out of the mouth of the star?

Even people who are considered real singers, like, say, Bruce Springsteen and Jennifer Hudson, perform alongside pre-recorded vocals. During the Super Bowl, when Hudson sang the national anthem and Bruce did the half-time show, they weren't out there without a safety net. They used backing tracks--although Bruce sang live, his band was pre-recorded, and it looks like Hudson might have been singing along to a pre-recorded track with a pre-recorded vocal. Why would a spot-on singer like Jennifer Hudson even think of doing that? Because 70,000 people were there screaming, and it's hard to hear yourself sing when 70,000 people are screaming. (And as American Idol has taught us, it's hard for some people to hear themselves sing when no one is screaming.)

On the master list of lip-synching scandals, Jennifer Hudson and Britney Spears rank pretty low, and we expect both of their careers to survive. Others have not been so lucky. Before Ashlee Simpson was in possession of a perfect nose and a rock star husband, she played Saturday Night Live and was humiliated when the song her band started playing was not the same as the pre-recorded one broadcast. Oops! She did an awkward little jig that will live in infamy and then stood there until it was all over. And after that it really almost was all over.

But the most famous moment in lip-synching history involves two dudes in dreads, one Grammy award, and one very public returning of said Grammy award. In 1990, Milli Vanilli won Best New Artist at the Grammys. It was later discovered that they had neglected to actually sing on their album. Even Britney wouldn't try to pull that one off. We think.


958 Comments

1. DUDE -
Britney Spears?...Lip-Synching?...Surely you jest!

2. DAVID B -
Who cares. She can't sing anyway.

3. Yahoo! Music User -
y would britney lip synch...its not gonna make ppl like her if she sounds better, it couldn't be tht much worse...hmmmmm

4. Yahoo! Music User -
**cough, cough**
Scank!

5. Angel -
what if she sang the song and they dubed the song to the video to make it look like it was song on site

6. Yahoo! Music User -
even though no-one likes her she has made millions on her hair due that got raves for not having any yet she still got paid and noone said go home you make me sick with disguest instead they were just like monkeys curious about the girl and what she was up to next and if she was going to make up cry or blink just doesn't matter cause she is just like us she has feelings she just doesn't show hers so much to the world as we do we don't have a camera stuck in our face everywhere we go just on holidays and that's enough to make u want to hide.

7. kenzy* -
omg this is funny

8. ramon -
Automatic Login Terms of Service - Please read carefully

Your use of automatic login with third party sites is at your sole risk. While Yahoo! takes measures to protect the privacy and integrity of your user data and has implemented security controls governing external companies, Yahoo! cannot guarantee the integrity of the third parties to whom you have granted access your account or permission to handle your user data. Yahoo! also cannot guarantee that your data will be protected at all times or that such third party won't mishandle or misuse your data once these third party companies have been granted access to the Yahoo! systems and network on your behalf. To better understand how this third party treats your personal information, please read their privacy policy.

Yahoo! assumes no responsibility and shall not be liable for any damages whatsoever in connection with any third party's access to Yahoo!'s network on your behalf or any mishandling or misuse of your data therefrom. Yahoo! makes no representations or warranties as to any possible acts or omissions of such third parties or any other aspect of the automatic login process.

You hereby forever release and hold harmless Yahoo! and its related entities, officers, directors, employees, agents, successors and assigns from and against any damages, harm, claims, expenses or other liability in connection with any access provided to third parties to the Yahoo! network on your behalf, including without limitation the misuse or mishandling of your data, even if advised of the possibility of such liability.

Remember, your use of Yahoo! through any third party, including your submission of any information or materials to Yahoo! through a third party, is at all times subject to the Yahoo! Terms of Service located at http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/.

Yahoo! reserves the right to modify these Legal Terms and Disclaimer at any time without notice. Your acknowledgement and consent to these Legal Terms and Disclaimer will mean that you have accepted the following disclaimer and any subsequent modifications.

9. Kenny -
3. DAVID B - Fri Mar 6, 2009 10:23pm PST
Who cares. She can't sing anyway.

+1!

10. Jill P -
i don't really care if britney is lip-synching. she can totally sing, and she's finally back on track. so why ruin it for her? give her a break, i mean its not that big of a deal, and even if she was lip synching its not like it noticable like kanye west was on snl. i love u britney!!!

11. __A_YAHOO_USER__ -
Why I am not surprised, I'll never know.

12. Yahoo! Music User -
Blender and Britney were made for each other.
Her tour will not last, like her last one.
Fake injury = low ticket sales. There is nothing real or original about her now. She is a follower now. When she was young and on star search, she actually sang live. I don't think she has sung live ever since. Go into the studio sing into a live mic. Her manufactured music has no relevance. Nobody cares.

13. Yahoo! Music User -
look i went to the concert i even have the album!i would so be able to tell i say she did not and you people are just trying to ruin her carrier!so stop!why dont you become a famous rock star shave your head bald and get that many fans that fast!all you haters are DORKS

14. Bob -
I don't care who you are or what has happened in your life. If you are a true professional of your talent, then you should not lip-sync. Its stealing money from the fans who payed hard working wages to see a singer sing their songs and put on a show. Everyone who would want to go to a Britney Spears concert needs to be shot anyway.

15. aditya -
RIHANNA ITS OKE!!!

16. Raj Barrek -
I like how people keep stating that "if she were really talented she'd be able to sing it all live."

Really? Have you ever SEEN an /entire/ Britney Spears concert? Her concert contains more cardio than some sporting events, and you expect someone to sing live? You could take the strongest vocalist out there and put them in Brit's shoes: if you can't catch your breath, it doesn't matter HOW well you can sing. Period.

This crap about "ripping her fans" off by lipsyncing is bogus, too. Her fans go see to see HER and to see a good SHOW. So WHAT if the vocals are dubbed? This is SUCH old news that I cannot believe it's continually brought up. The girl's been doing this since she came on the scene ten years ago. Get over it already. At least it's HER voice to begin with.

17. Green -
Give me a break its so ovious and i mean HELLO
linsey lohan lip sings
hannah motana (not as miley) does
selena gomez does
sometimes ashlee simpson does
BUT HELLO they are ppl

18. sara -
salam

19. erica -
Who cares if she lyp syncs, she is the one, the only, Ms. Britney Spears. You can say whatever you want about her. Every morning when she wakes ups, she wakes up a millionaire, and the most famous person in the whole world. Name one person who has all the fame she has.

20. erica -
Raj Barrek is right. I have been to two of her concerts. Sadly I she's not bringing her circus tour to my town. But anyway. no one can sing live while doing all her dance moves that she does. her shows are work-outs. Try going to a aerobics class and spending just one hour there and sing while working out. then try that for another two hours. see if you can do it. and yes. LEAVE BRITNEY ALONE!!!!!!
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Chris Willman
26
As Heard On...
by Rebecca Harper, Hulu
46
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
141
Framed
by John Kordosh
119
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
332
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
221
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
332
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Justin Mathews
183
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
123
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
580
Rock's Backpages
by Philip Norman (1970)
191
Stop The Presses!
by Us Magazine
85
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
125
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
88
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
49
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
78
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
515
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
71
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
59

Pinetop Perkins' 80-year career still going

AP
Fri Nov 27, 2009 4:03am PST

AP - Noisy crowds in smoky bars don't bother 96-year-old bluesman Pinetop Perkins. It's all part of his job. Most nights, after he snuffs out his menthol cigarette, Perkins slides onto the piano bench in some club and … More »

More Music News