Music Blogs

Week Ending May 25, 2008: David Vs. David, The Showdown Moves To The Charts

Posted Thu May 29, 2008 8:53pm PDT by Paul Grein in Chart Watch

David Cook and David Archuleta take their friendly competition from the set of American Idol to the national pop charts. Cook places a staggering 17 songs on the top 200 Hot Digital Songs chart. His bevy of hits includes the new #1, "Time Of My Life," which opens with a healthy total of 236,000 downloads. Cook's 17 entries have a combined total of 944,000 paid downloads. I don't think he'll need to go back to bartending anytime soon.

Archuleta places 12 songs on the Hot Digital Songs chart, topped by his cover of John Lennon's "Imagine," which opens at #16 with 71,000 downloads. Archie's songs have a combined total of 301,000 paid downloads. Thus, Cook was downloaded more than three times as often as his rival. That's an even more lopsided result than last week's voting, which Cook won by a margin of 56% to 44%. (If Archie had won the title, would he be dominating the download battle? Probably. America loves a winner.)

Cook's new entries also include "Dream Big" (#7, 111,000 downloads), his cover of U2's "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" (#9, 98,000), his cover of Collective Soul's "The World I Know" (#14, 80,000), his cover of Aerosmith's "I Don't Want To Miss A Thing" (#21, 60,000), and his cover of Michael Jackson's "Billie Jean" (#24, 56,000).

Third place finisher Syesha Mercado isn't represented in the top 200, but fourth-place finisher Jason Castro has two entries--his cover of Jeff Buckley's "Hallelujah" (#81, 19,000 downloads) and his cover of  Israel Kamakawiwo'ole's "Somewhere Over The Rainbow" (#102, 16,000).

Fifth place finisher Brooke White opens at #136 with her cover of the Beatles' "Let It Be" (12,000 downloads). Eighth-place finisher Michael Johns bows at #187 with his cover of Aerosmith's "Dream On" (9,000).

Five of the original versions of these songs also receive a spike. Collective Soul's "The World I Know" ranks #67 (23,000), Kamakawiwo'ole's "Somewhere Over The Rainbow" is #133 (12,000), Buckley's "Hallelujah" ranks #139 (12,000), U2's "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For" is #148 (11,000) and Lennon's "Imagine" is #175 (10,000).

Several of the guests on the Idol finale, including OneRepublic, George Michael, Bryan Adams and ZZ Top, also surge this week.

This bodes well for the debut albums by Cook and Archuleta. I hereby predict that Cook will get off to a faster start than Jordin Sparks did in November, when she opened with sales of 119,000. But Sparks has slowly but surely turned her album into a hit. As of this week, it has sold 778,000 copies-which tops the Season 5 winner, Taylor Hicks, whose debut album has sold 702,000 copies.

On this week's album chart, 3 Doors Down lands its second straight #1 as 3 Doors Down debuts in the lead position. The band's previous album, Seventeen Days, achieved the same feat in February 2005. The band's tenure at #1 will, however, be brief. Usher will debut on top next week with his first album in four years, Here I Am. Usher's last album, Confessions, debuted with sales of 1,096,000. If he does even half as well this time, he'll have the biggest opening of 2008. (Hey, no pressure, Usher.)

3 Doors Down is one of those acts whose sales outstrip their fame. The rock quintet from Mississippi has sold 11,609,000 albums since it broke through in 2000. Only two rock acts that have emerged in this decade--Linkin Park (20,199,000) and Nickelback (16,561,000)--have sold more albums. Including acts from all genres, 3 Doors Down is in the top 10 among acts that first hit the album chart in this decade. Nelly heads this list with sales of 20,917,000 albums, followed by Linkin Park, Josh Groban, Rascal Flatts, Nickelback, Norah Jones, 50 Cent, Alicia Keys, Ludacris and 3 Doors Down.

Avril Lavigne, Coldplay, John Mayer, Keith Urban, Pink, Evanescence and Kelly Clarkson are next in line on the list of top-selling album acts that have broken through since 2000. Just about all of the acts in this cluster of names are more famous than 3 Doors Down, but 3 Doors Down has sold more albums.

The band's 2000 debut album, The Better Life, has sold 5,475,000 copies. But it did it the hard way. The album debuted at #104 and took 28 weeks to reach its #7 peak. The band's 2002 follow-up, Away From The Sun, has sold 3,779,000 copies. It debuted at #8, which is also where it peaked. Even though they didn't reach #1, those albums built the fan base that allowed the group's last two albums to debut in the top spot.

(One of the 3 Doors Down's founding members, Daniel Adair, left the line-up in January 2005 to join Nickelback. Since Nickelback has sold more albums than 3 Doors Down, I guess you could say he traded up.)

Here's the low-down on this week's top 10 albums.

1. 3 Doors Down, 3 Doors Down, 154,000. This total is down from the first-week sales total of the band's last album, Seventeen Days, which opened with sales of 231,000. "It's Not My Time" jumps from #27 to #17 on Hot Digital Songs. "Here Without You" jumps from #193 to #153. A third song, "Train," opens at #191.

2. Bun B, II Trill, 98,000. This new entry is Bun B's first album since the death in December of Chad "Pimp C" Butler, his partner in UGK. That rap duo opened at #1 in August with its fifth album, Underground Kingz-which is what UGK is short for. Bun B's first solo album, Trill, peaked at #6 in November 2005. Bun B's "Damn I'm Cold" bows at #137 on Hot Digital Songs.

3. Julianne Hough, Julianne Hough, 67,000. This new entry is the country singing debut by Hough, a two-time winner on ABC-TV's Dancing With The Stars. Hough's single, "That Song In My Head," bows at #70 on Hot Digital Songs. Hough will be the opening act on Brad Paisley's summer tour.

4. Frank Sinatra, Nothing But The Best, 54,000. The classy retrospective covering Sinatra's two decades on Warner Bros.' Reprise label (1961-1981) slips from #2 to #4 in its second week in the top 10. It overtakes the album that kept it from #1 last week (see #5), but a lot of good that does Frank now. The album features collaborations with Count Basie & His Orchestra, Antonio Carlos Jobim and Nancy Sinatra.

5. Death Cab for Cutie, Narrow Stairs, 53,000. Last week's #1 album slips to #5 in its second week in the top 10. "I Will Possess Your Heart" falls from #48 to #85 on Hot Digital Songs.

6. Leona Lewis, Spirit, 50,000. Lewis slips a notch to #6 in her seventh week in the top 10. "Bleeding Love" drops from #2 to #5 on Hot Digital Songs.

7. Mariah Carey, E=MC2, 45,000. This slips a notch to #7 in its sixth week in the top 10. It's just 68,000 copies away from becoming the second album to top the 1 million mark in 2008. "Touch My Body" drops from #16 to #38 on Hot Digital Songs. "Bye Bye" falls from #38 to #46.

8. Duffy, Rockferry, 44,000. The Welsh singer's debut slips from #4 to #8 in its second week in the top 10. "Mercy" drops from #13 to #23 on Hot Digital Songs.

9. Madonna, Hard Candy, 39,000. This slips a notch to #9 in its fourth week in the top 10. "4 Minutes," Madonna's smash collabo with Justin Timberlake, drops from #5 to #8 on Hot Digital Songs.

10. Neil Diamond, Home Before Dark, 36,000. This falls from #7 to #10 in its third week in the top 10. It's Diamond's first album to spend more than one week in the top 10 since The Christmas Album spent three weeks there in 1992. It's his best showing by a non-holiday album since Heartlight had four weeks in the winners circle in 1982.

Three albums drop out of the top 10 this week. Jason Mraz's We Sing, We Dance, We Steal Things drops from #3 to #11, Toby Keith's 35 Biggest Hits dips from #9 to #13 and Keith Sweat's Just Me plummets from #10 to #38.

Jesse McCartney's Departure opens at #14.  This is the 21-year old heartthrob's highest charting album to date. His first two studio albums, Beautiful Soul and Right Where You Want Me, both peaked at #15. McCartney's single, "Leavin'," dips from #9 to #11 on Hot Digital Songs. "It's Over" vaults from #125 to #77. McCartney is receiving very large checks for co-writing (with Ryan Tedder of OneRepublic) Leona Lewis' international smash, "Bleeding Love."

Donna Summer's Crayons opens at #17, becoming her highest-charting album since She Works Hard For The Money went top 10 in 1983. Summer debuted in 1975 with Love To Love You Baby, which brought eroticism to mainstream female pop and helped set the stage for Madonna. Summer was, of course, the queen of disco, which proved to be both a blessing and a curse. When disco died, circa 1980, many wrote Summer off, even though her talent transcended just one genre. What people missed back then is that many of her hits, including "Last Dance," "Heaven Knows" and "On The Radio" were deeply moving pop ballads--just set to a dance beat.

Foxboro Hot Tubs' Stop Drop And Roll!!! debuts at #21. The ‘60s-shaded album is a fun side-project by Green Day, which logged three weeks at #1 with its last studio album, American Idiot. (Green Day's sense of humor has been on display from the beginning. In 2001 they came up with a marvelously dry title for their greatest hits set, International Superhits!)

The soundtrack to Indiana Jones And The Kingdom Of The Crystal Skull bows at #39. It's the highest-charting soundtrack in this long-running series, which has been scored by Oscar winner John Williams. The soundtrack to the initial Raiders Of The Lost Ark reached #62 in 1981. Indiana Jones And The Temple Of Doom hit #42 in 1984. Indiana Jones And The Last Crusade failed to chart in 1989.

Flobots' Fight With Tools vaults from #183 to #15, on the strength of the hit single "Handlebars" (which climbs to #34 on Hot Digital Songs). The album's sales increased by 697%, a greater increase than any other album in the top 200. On the down side, Filter's Anthems For The Damned drops from #60 to #167 in its second week. The album's sales declined by 64%, the steepest decline of any album in the top 200.

Catalog Report: Time/Life's three-CD set I Can Only Imagine: Ultimate Power Anthems Of The Christian Faith is #1 on the Catalog Albums chart for the fifth week. It sold 17,000 copies and would have ranked #25 if older, catalog titles were allowed to compete on the big chart.

Police Work: Twenty-five years ago this week, The Police's "Every Breath You Take" entered Billboard's Hot 100. The song topped the chart for eight weeks, longer than any other 1983 single. It brought Sting the Grammy for Song of the Year--the only one of the "Big Three" Grammy Awards (Album, Record and Song of the Year) that Michael Jackson did not win that year. In 1997, Puff Daddy sampled the song for "I'll Be Missing You," his heartfelt tribute to The Notorious B.I.G., who had been killed a few months earlier. The track, which also featured Faith Evans and 112, was #1 for 11 weeks-longer even than The Police's original.

Heads Up: Due next week, in addition to Usher's Here I Stand, are Al Green's Lay It Down and the Sex And The City soundtrack. Green's album features duets with Corinne Bailey Rae and John Legend.

299 Comments

161. cha -
David Archuleta should have won American Idol. He ROCKS!!!

162. Yahoo! Music User -
cook rocks!! he can sing anything! pretty boy!!! star quality! yeahhhhhhhhhhh!

archie fanatics, it's about time you accept defeat! you are embarrassing archie with all your sour graping. lol

163. s -
You all who keep talking about the "Cook Cougars" need to just drop that. Just because a woman is older and thinks that David Cook was the top performer doesn't mean that she would be interested in a young kid romantically.

If one of the women voted 400 times, that is just sad and is basically an abuse of the system - I can guarantee that there were 400 OTHER people wanting to vote one time for David Cook, who couldn't get through because this woman had the phone lines tied up, as they were each time I tried to call in to vote once for David Cook. I didn't call in and vote for him after the midway point, because I was busy and would then forget and feel guilty later. Obviously, he won without my vote.

Prior to that, I had called in after each show and voted once for each of these contestants: David Cook, David A, Brooke, Jason, and Michael Johns. Oh and for Carly and Kristy. Even though I'm not a big country fan, I thought Kristy was a beautiful girl who had potential in the country field and I was glad she had the spunk to prove Simon wrong. (By the way, although I think Simon can be blunt and a little too hard on the kids; but by and large, I think that he is the only honest and good opinion amongst the judges.)

These kids are nice kids. They all had some performances that were good and some performances that weren't so good. A few had performances that were embarrasingly bad. Some consistently had pitch problems throughout the show. Those kids just aren't good enough to be musical stars. Some will have moderately successful careers, some will have really good careers, and some need to get an education and go on with a career in another field, because they're just not good enough. Very few had star personalities.

What blew my mind was when I watched the Country Music Awards several weeks ago to hear one performer, and I heard several award-winning groups who weren't good singers, AT ALL! One male group had a lead singer who was so off-key that I could not believe my ears. I suppose that in a studio setting, that can be minimized or something; but I found myself thinking that this man and several others were worse than the worst of the twelve Idol competitors. So, that blows the theory that I read on this site that you can't be successful if you can't sing well.

But the real reason I watched Idol each week was to hear David Cook and to make sure he didn't lose because I forgot to vote for him.

And, Sam L, why drag Eva Cassidy into this discussion? I agree that Eva was one of the most talented singers who has every lived, but very few performers who have fame and fortune from singing can come close to Eva's performances. David Cook sings in a totally different way than Eva; and it doesn't mean that he is mediocre. David Cook is as talented as at least 90% of the big selling performers today.

I totally agree with Yahoo Music Teacher. David C's fan base exploded, probably after "Billie Jean".

164. filmlight -
I suspect that after the two Idols complete their home town visit, Idol exec's then determine who will be the winner. I've only
watched 2-3 seasons and it seems the best singer expected to win, then loses. There were reports that the exec's were favoring
D. Cook a couple of weeks before the finale.
Arch was the better singer & he should have
won. I'm sure both David's will be successful. Personally, I also liked Kristy
Lee Cook. Is she recording or did she give up? All the contestants were good singers - but don't like the hard look. viewers didn't like it either. Best of luck to all of you!

165. Hans -
archie is the best !! my sister and i was inspired to his songs .. he is my idolatry !! wuhooo !!

166. LuisC -
Think DA will be in the San Francisco Bay area soon? Would mind having him as a special quest performer at our event next week Friday. Unfortunately, we are a non-profit organization with very little funds. Know if he'd consider doing it for charity?

167. baby s. -
I wonder why some insist it's archie that should have won. I watched AI7 from the day it first aired here in the Philippines. I love archie since i saw him first but it was david cook who impressed me with the richness of his voice. I have admired him since his audition video and I am so glad he won. I love to watch them both but I love watching and hearing david cook more even on replays.

168. LuisC -
Deep in my heart of souls I thought David A. would have won. Their music was completely different and often times David Cook wasn't even to confident about himself. Define IDOL and you'll get the point. For a 17 y/o David A. was born a star!

169. LuisC -
Girlfriend, don't you know that replays can often play tricks on you? And, the more you hear it the less you'll pickup on it because it's already engrained in your head...

170. Kim -
cook rocks my socks big time

171. rommel -
wow.....d cook was terrif....terif...terrific indeed. he deserved to be called the best AI winner.

172. Nike T -
some people said that David A can only sing ballad, but i personnaly don't think so, like Randy said, he can sing anything, even media people label him as a prodigy. What's there to debate of his natural talent.

173. No Quitter -
Life is hard enough to readjust for these contestants without the constant microscope over their entire day. Let them take a breath and make their own decisions. All the hounds waiting for them to fail should attend to their own lives.

174. Yahoo! Music User -
HERE I STAND....
HERE I STAND.

175. Yahoo! Music User -
you made a mistake when you first mentioned usher's album...

176. pLaYa -
yeah,,.. david c hav a gr8 voices, i like him but i love dav a cause he got diff styles not like david c that only hav the husky rockers voice, he's voice is pretty cmmon, he sound's like nickleback vocalzz., anyhow david a hav a gr8 voice either got style's if he develop it mor he'll do gr8 things plus he's young he got so much option's er choices to pick from... anyways goodluck for d both David's... y'all rock

177. tinkerbell -
Now, now, Liz D. Play nice.

178. Yahoo! Music User -
Daughtry is still better than cook

179. Peggy -
THE ONLY REASON THAT COOK WON INSTEAD OF ARCHIE IS BECAUSE HE HAS THE STAGE PRESENCE THAT ARCHIE DOESN'T HAVE, I HOPED DAVID COOK WOULD WIN AND EVEN SIMON SAID IT ON THE TONITE SHOW THAT HE HOPED DAVID COOK WOULD WIN. ARCHIE IS TO SHY ACTING HE'S GOT TO OPEN UP A LIL MORE CMON NOW GIVE CREDIT WERE CREDIT IS DUE! AMERICA DID GREAT!

180. Ken Osha -
Paul.
Don't show you picture on the website or have it retaken.


Regards,
Ken Osha
Page:  5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Chris Willman
26
As Heard On...
by Rebecca Harper, Hulu
46
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
141
Framed
by John Kordosh
119
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
332
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
221
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
332
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Justin Mathews
183
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
123
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
581
Rock's Backpages
by Philip Norman (1970)
191
Stop The Presses!
by Us Magazine
85
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
125
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
88
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
49
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
78
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
515
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
71
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
59

Jackson's `This Is It' out on DVD in January

AP
Mon Nov 30, 2009 1:02pm PST

AP - "Michael Jackson's This Is It," a film about the King of Pop's final rehearsals before his death, will be released on DVD on Jan. 26, 2010. The DVD release was announced Monday by Sony Pictures Home Ente… More »

More Music News
Loading...