Do You REALLY Have to Comeback?
Over the past couple of weeks, we've had the Jackson 5, Led Zeppelin, and Guns 'N Roses all threaten to return with new tours or albums. One of the oldest truisms of rock 'n' roll is this: every band on the way down is a band on the way up. Just as soon as your favorite artist becomes cliché, cheesy, and dated you can be sure they'll return to remind everyone why they mattered in the first place.
Or not.
Frankly, some bands don't ever need to come back (that means you, Asia). Some bands forget what a comeback means (hint: if you leave half the band at home it's not a comeback). The road is littered with bands looking for your comeback vote. It's often a desperate act by groups who should've stayed in the rehearsal hall rather than appearing on a stadium stage. Here's a list of the year's most ill-advised returns. While they're out touring, I'll be at home listening to their albums.
Led Zeppelin
Robert Plant got it right. He agreed to play one gig for the late, great Ahmet Ertegun, the founder of Atlantic Records who signed Zep to the label. The gig was a success by all accounts, and Plant went on to tour with Alison Krauss in support of their insanely beautiful roots record, Raising Sand. Meanwhile, the rest of the Zep say they want to keep playing and that they'll find a new singer to fill in for Plant. WHAT? Has anyone told Jimmy and John Paul about that Journey reunion without Steve Perry?
Smashing Pumpkins
Billy Corgan invites the drummer, leaves everyone else at home, and calls it a reunion. Sorry, we call it self-indulgence.
Jackson 5
Does anyone need to see the Jackson sideshow on parade again? Not even Michael has the courage to go through with it.
The Cure
There should be a rule. Dudes over 25 can't wear mascara and lipstick. In the '80s the look was sensitive and cool. Now, it's just creepy.
Mötley Crüe
Their recent Saints of Los Angeles comes nowhere close to their late-'80s alcohol-induced heyday, but I give total props to Mick Mars. Battling a hip replacement and a degenerative spine disease, he's still able to play punishingly loud. That's gotta count for something.
New Kids on the Block
What's worse than a teenaged, bubblegum Boston boy band? A middle-aged, bubblegum Boston boy band. Life is hard enough without this sad display.
Check out our FlipBook of Great Rock 'n Roll Comebacks.
Drop by GetBack.com for your daily dose of pop culture pleasure -- music, movies, games, and more.
ME. . . no. I was a HUGE Van Hagar fan. It was the definition of fun. You heard it in their music. . . the last tour w/Sammy, was sad, and bad. You could feel the tension. Here, Ed was SO against doing a "greatest hits album, because it meant that VH was giving up, and it pissed him off. . . Fast Forward, add "Cubic Zirconium Dave", back into the fray, and voila. . . greatest hits tour?. . . VH had WAY more commercial success with Sam, and the music showed the fun. . . Hypocrite?. . . you bet. Was the tour a sucess?. . . you be the judge.
I didnt go. . . and everyone I know that did. . . said. . . EHHHH!. . . it was alright. Not GREAT. . . but okay.
You're acting as if the the adult Jacksons didn't out-sell and out-perform groups like The Rolling Stones in the 80s and 90s.
You're wrong for that.
anyone who thinks other wise is crazy..
their concert was insane and all my friends that went say the same..