Music Blogs

Miley Cyrus: Not A Girl, Not Yet A Woman

Posted Wed Mar 4, 2009 5:24pm PST by Lyndsey Parker in As Heard On...
Most teen stars don't age so gracefully--anyone who's watched hasbeen-centric "Celebreality" shows like Confessions Of A Teen Idol, Breaking Bonaduce, or The Two Coreys knows this. For every success story like Jodie Foster or Drew Barrymore, there's...well, a whole bunch of Coreys, so to speak.

Miley Cyrus, at ripe old age of 16, is the latest t(w)een star hoping to smoothly transition from pimple-prone pubescent to respected adult entertainer (no, not THAT kind of adult entertainer!), with her relatively mature new song, "The Climb." The country-crossover power ballad (is that her daddy's influence?) may be the theme from the latest installment in her kiddie-friendly Hannah Montana movie series, but it's a much more subdued affair than her past bubblegummy efforts. "Pumpin' Up The Party" it ain't.

In the song's "serious" video, an older and presumably wiser Miley even straps on a guitar (surely she must know how to play it, right? right???); stands triumphantly on a CGI-rendered cliff beneath an aerial-sweeping camera (a scene lifted straight out of an '80s Bon Jovi video); and existentially sings the following grown-up words of woe:

I can almost see it, that dream I'm dreaming
But there's a voice inside my head saying, "You'll never reach it"
Every step I'm taking, every move I make
Feels lost with no direction
My faith is shaking but I got to keep trying
Got to keep my head held high

There's always gonna be another mountain
I'm always gonna want to make it move
Always going to be an uphill battle
Sometimes I'm gonna have to lose
Ain't about how fast I get there
Ain't about what's waiting on the other side
It's the climb

Whoa. That's deep. For Miley, at least.

Of course, the whole song/video is reminiscent of former teen sensation Britney Spears' attempt at mature balladry some years ago--also from a movie, Crossroads--"I'm Not A Girl, Not Yet A Woman." The video is even eerily similar, right down to the widescreen aerial cliff shots, road-tripping movie scenes, and inspirational Hallmark-card lyrics about how "this girl will always find her way" and "all I need is time":

Well, we all know Britney's post-movie evolution from girl to woman wasn't exactly an easy one. Will Miley, now at a crossroads herself, encounter a similarly bumpy road? It remains to be seen, but if the subdued sound and triumph-of-the-spirit sentiments of "The Climb" are any indication, there probably won't be any head-shaving or underwear-forgetting incidents in Miley's future.

318 Comments

101. Yahoo! Music User -
Sadly, this kid cannot sing to save her life! Just because who her Daddy is, they put her out there. She needs to give it up. Someone should just be honest with her and tell her that she can't sing OR act.

102. David -
All is well in the factory, right Miley? Are you happy there? Radiohead wants you over the rainbow....

103. Yahoo! Music User -
who the heck will be haten on miley!!!!!!!wat does she have that u want....yea she got fame and fortune but shes going through a lot of problems wit her photo scandals and her problem wit saying things that she should have not said....how would u feel if everyone knows u in a bad way..u wouldnt feel the way that u feel know.....theres popularity and then theres too much popularity...im not backen Miley Cyrus up,i reaaly am agianst her...i just think she has wayy to much issues in her head and in dis world.....She needs to go bak to wen she came from and then come bak to earth and smell the coffe cuz she obivously dont kno wat she deeling wit...WELL MILEY CYRUS UR DEELIN WIT FIRE!!!!

104. Yahoo! Music User -
I was so surprised when Miley sung that song!! I had no idea she could sing a song like that!!! It really was great!!! I think it's tone is better than like her old hannah montana and miley songs!!! That song can speak to anyone who's having trouble in life!!! If you can dream it you can do it!!! That song is a big leap for her!!! I wouldn't be surprised if this song causes her next cd to soar!!!You go girl!!! Go MILEY!!!!

105. Yahoo! Music User -
twilight is way better than hannah montana or jonas brothers or any singer except paramore and hsm,hsm2,hsm3

106. Allison -
I find it oh so amusing how the fan's of Miley can't spell to save their lives. She honestly sucks. Now, her half-brother Trace on the other hand... :D

107. Yahoo! Music User -
Miley Cyrus sings awesome. I also love that song. I herd it and now I have it stuck in my head!!!

108. Yasmeen -
the climb is so inspirational. i love you miley, keep your head held high

109. Yahoo! Music User -
i never did like miley cyrus. i think britney spears is better at singing and miley is better at acting.

110. CBE -
What an obnoxious music video that is. Someone ought to tell her that flailing around with your arms outstretched is not the makings of a good video. The song isn't half bad, but everything about that video is tacky and annoying.

111. Marissa -
u guys should leave her and britney alone.day never did anything 2 u.wat happened 2 dem or their behavior is none of ur business.mind ur own.u guys should seriously get a life if ur gonna b pickn on people dat isnt rite.n der r other people dat lyke dat kind of music n if u dont den just dont b involve or look @ things dat invlove briteny or miley.get a life

112. Yahoo! Music User -
come on people...just leave the girl alone. how would u like it if people said mean stuff about u???

113. Yahoo! Music User -
i think that miley rox and i don't care if u think against it.

114. Blah -
Too bad Christina Augulera had a stronger voice at what 10? She just doesn't have a strong or "pretty" voice.

115. Yahoo! Music User -
Radiohead Mileycyrus Jonas Brothers anyday.

116. First L -
she's overrated and she really needs to grow up honestly the things she is doing are very immature, not trying to be mean, but her dad needs to have a better hold on her i mean after all she is only 16 or whatever...

117. thomas t -
radiohead made a statement and it pissed
off a young pop singer. I like Avril Lavigne.
She Rocks. I also like Joan Jett and the BLackHeart. These girls never let that get in their way. Miley should not have jumped so quickly with her statement about "ruin".
She needs to write a song about the word.
I always liked her fathers music. Way before she was born.

thomas
concerned fan from TEXAS, SAN ANGELO ON THE CONCHO

118. Yahoo! Music User -
i'm not going to be weak and attack how miley cyrus looks. that's just lame and unfair. but her music, however, is fair play. and, in my opinion, it is not good. it has no originality. if you want a simple song to sing along to, then great...but if you're looking for something with staying power, look elsewhere.

i'm just not a fan of cyrus and probably never will be. and that whole thing with radiohead? grow up. nobody can get everything they want. and miley does not have the power to "ruin" them. they, at least, have some originality.

119. Jaime L -
I bet she gets knocked up pretty soon. There's pics of her making out w/ tons of guys.

120. Lorelai -
Good song, but the wrong person singing it. I would like it more if someone a little older sang it. Or at least someone that has gone through some hardship to get as popular as Miley Cyrus. What "mountain" has she had to climb recently?
Page:  2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Paul Grein
30
As Heard On...
by Lyndsey Parker
48
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
148
Framed
by John Kordosh
123
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
345
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
238
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
337
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Andy Pemberton
199
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
126
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
609
Rock's Backpages
by Ben Myers (1999)
199
Stop The Presses!
by Lyndsey Parker
88
That's Really Week
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
128
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
92
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
50
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
80
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
532
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
74
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
66

Terrorist attack feared after Jackson arrest

AP
Tue Dec 22, 2009 10:46pm PST

AP - Police concerns that media-hungry terrorists would attack Michael Jackson's trial as a "soft target" led to a request for federal help, according to FBI files kept on the late pop star. The documents also … More »

More Music News