The Destiny's Child Blessing And Curse

Posted Wed Jun 11, 2008 5:23pm PDT by Billy Johnson, Jr. in Hip-Hop Media Training

I think Beyonce is an alien. Baby girl is out of this world. The first time I saw Destiny's Child's "No, No, No" video, I knew she was the star. LeToya was easily my No. 2. Kelly was fly, and LaTavia was cool.

I never understood why some question Beyonce's vocal talent. Maybe it's because she emerged in an era that focuses so much on image that any other female singer who looks as good as her can't sing that well. So the fact that Beyonce is beautiful, can dance and makes pop music means that like Britney, Janet and Madonna, her voice is thin.

Beyonce's bubblegum chewy lyrics are corn on the cob, but her voice is pure and impresses without music accompaniment. Don't let her sweet face fool you.

It's no surprise that Beyonce has evolved into one of the biggest music acts of the last 10 years. But she really isn't the topic. The subject is her offspring-- Destiny's Child members Kelly and Michelle and her baby sister Solange, who have been working diligently to establish themselves independent of Jay-Z's new bride. Their association and work put in alongside Bey assures that opportunities come their way. But successfully transitioning out of Beyonce's shadow hasn't been easy.

Kelly Rowland has found moderate success with minor acting roles and scored her biggest look to date on the song "Dilemma" which she recorded with Nelly. Her albums Simply Deep (2002) and Ms. Kelly (2007) were anticipated, but failed to make the impact warranted for a member of the top-selling girl group. Ms. Kelly was repackaged and released in March. It was promoted with a new single "Daylight" featuring Gym Class Heroes it-boy Travis McCoy. But unfortunately Ms. Kelly: Diva Deluxe drew less attention than the original release.

It really makes no sense that Kelly hasn't been able to establish herself as a solo artist. She can sing a lot better than Ciara, can dance, is poised and gorgeous. The problem is that she is stuck in Beyonce's shadow.

Her image always mirrors Beyonce and much of her music sounds like outtakes from Beyonce's albums. Additionally, there is limited promotion behind her records. She feels pushed on the back burner. Hopefully, one day, she will get her due.

When attending the Southern California stop of the Destiny Fulfilled...And Lovin' It tour in 2005, I come up with a nickname for Michelle Williams: "The Luckiest Girl In The World." Think about. Her intro to the limelight was walking across the backs of LeToya and LaTavia onto the set of Destiny's Child's "Say My Name" video shoot, and poof, a couple months later she was on the stage next to Beyonce and Kelly receiving a Grammy for a record she did not record. But you can't be mad at her. Anybody in her shoes would have done the same. (Well, except for that other girl Farrah Franklin, who joined D.C. at the same time as Michelle, but left soon after. I haven't even seen her on a reality show since. Her career can't be going too well.)

Even if you don't believe in karma, you have to admit that Michelle has done something good to someone at some point in this life or a past one.

So while I'm sitting at D.C. concert at the Arrowhead Pond, minutes away from Disneyland, it's time for Michelle's solo set. When Michelle's segment starts, everyone in the arena sits down, clearly expecting to be bored out of their minds.

But Michelle is one smart woman who knows how to take advantage of an opportunity. She knows that the only thing the audience knew about her was that she was the other girl in D.C. whose awkward nasal tone feels out of place on her obligatory verses on "Survivor" and "Soldier." She was the other girl in D.C. who released a couple gospel albums.

But when Michelle starts singing her gospel song "Do You Know" she puts her heart into it. Her voice is a good fit for the production. She resonates with the song's lyrics of triumph. Her five minutes of fame and then some play out as she sings. It is obvious that she has performed on Broadway, starring in the Elton John play Aida, which has previously been lead by powerhouses Toni Braxton and Heather Headley.

Michelle has been putting in the right type of artist development and has been receiving solid reviews playing Suge Avery in the traveling version of The Color Purple.

When I heard that she was planning to release a pop album, I thought that it could work, and I was curious. Her latest song "We Break The Dawn" is great and further shows her growth and comfort in her own space, garnering no comparisons to Beyonce but instead sonically feeling like old school Brandy and, in the video, taking us back to early Whitney. Michelle will definitely step from underneath the Beyonce umbrella with this release. I just hope she gets all the support from the media she needs to take off. She's earned it.

Solange, Beyonce's younger sister, probably has it the toughest. As the eldest child myself, I know how it goes with comparisons. I never had to deal with being compared to my siblings even when, for example, my brother was getting better grades. But I witnessed my brother and sister being measured up to me all the time. Pretty soon after Destiny's Child took off, Solange was also working on her music career. You can say that she accomplished what could be expected of a teenage music artist not immersed in the child-hit-making-machine called Disney. You'll find an album and dozens of old tracks on her artist page, but nothing memorable.

When I heard that Solange, now 21, would be releasing a new album, I immediately expected it to be a Beyonce Jr. project. I didn't necessarily think it would be a bad thing. That just seemed like the obvious direction. I knew she had performed with and co-written songs with the members of Destiny's Child, but my contact at Music World Music stressed that Solange had a different plan for herself. She told me that SoL-AngeL & Hadley Street Dreams was a ne-soul record as opposed to a hip hop R&B pop offering.

It turns out that Solange has recruited production from Pharrell, who did the first single "I Decided," Cee-Lo, Mark Ronson, and Q-Tip. All of these guys are excellent, and we all know how successful Mark Ronson has been with the throwback sounds from Amy Winehouse, but there are two names on Solange's list of producers/contributors that got my attention: 1) Raphael Saadiq is easily one of the most underrated producers. Plus, he has a gift for creating classic soul music in a style he calls instant vintage. 2) Lamont Dozier of the Holland-Dozier-Holland, who were responsible for writing so many early Motown hits, also contributes a song. I'm interested in hearing the rest of the record.

I like "I Decided." It's somewhat of a warm up track. It's light and feels good, and a nice way to reintroduce Solange. I'm very interested in hearing more of the album. Solange wrote a three page autobiography about her career and compared the record to music of the '60s and '70s. "I would like to think that it is as if The Supremes, The Marvelettes, Dusty Springfield and Minnie Riperton were to make the music they did with a modern touch," she said. If she can pull this off, she will easily be on the path of setting her accomplishments apart from those of her big superstar sis. I think she's made the right decision.



252 Comments

1. mooneysuccess -
Beyonce A+
Kelly B-
Michelle C
Solange C-
I see why Beyonce went solo. She is the one who made the group work. The others are pretty but not superbly talented. Beyonce push them to excellence, by themselves there just at a lower level. There lucky that Beyonce has been so nice and treats them like family hopefully at some point she will agree to a short reunion so they make some serious money. She will find some way to help them. But they simply can't share the stage with her for to long they hold her back. but with hard work and desire maybe they come up to higher grades. God bless them all.

2. melissa.wright77 -
I have to agree with you candyman1266, the young ladies are just as beautiful and talented. With the help of her father, mother, and the media keeping the focus on Beyonce she gets all the fame. I love Beyonce, but our people or the media did not shine the spot light nor give the other young ladies a chance.

3. melissa.wright77 -
moneysuccess and jmanchris you both are speaking from a narrow mind. You guys or ladies are being very sterotypical and prejudice. If you are a black American, you need to get out of that mind set of thinking and start accepting yourselves and loving your race.

4. Dani -
Kelly and Michelle's songs are nice, they both seem to have the same theme though... partying until the sun comes up. But Solange... seems like she is straining or trying to hard.

5. chloejannicejackson -
God loves Beyonce Knowles, and wants to use her. She is a special vessel, rare in this earth.

6. chester_nedd_1995 -
They All Hav Wat It Tkz 2 B A Solo Artists They Just Don't Know How To Approach The Solo Scene Obviuosly Kelly Can Take Notez Frm Michelle and Solange Because They Both Are Not Trying To Approach The Music Level Beyonce Is At They Are Trying To Go Beyond Her Level and They Are Off To A Good Start..... " Kelly My Prayers Are Out 4 U and Wish U More Sucess".......

7. ndidi a -
i think the publicity give to beyonce is highly overrated.

8. arj1100 -
WOW!!! THEY ALL HAVE WHAT IT TAKES!
WHAT IS VERY SAD TO ME,I GOT TO SEE A FAT
GIRL GROUP WHOM I LOVED.THE TRUTH IS THESE
LADIES NEVER HAD A CHANCE IN MAKING IT AS
A GIRL GROUP.WHY? YOU HAVE 4 TALENTED BLACK FEMALS IN ONE GROUP THAT CAN SING.THEY DID GREAT UNTIL CONTRACTS!PEOPLE CHANGE WHEN MONEY
IS IN THE MIX!MONEY MAKE MONEY AT ANY COST!THAT GO'S FOR FAMILY AND FRIENDS.SEEM TO ME FAMILY AND FRIENDS DROPED THE BALL!!!"ORIGINAL DESTINY CHILD WILL NOT GET BACK TOGETHER"!NOW ON THERE OWN THEY WILL HAVE SUCESS.NOW SOLANGE WILL HAVE TO BE COOL BEING HER SELF AN BEING GREAT AT WHAT SHE LOVE TO DO!

9. ksmithwilson -
We all know Beyonce is the STAR and will always be the STAR ,look at this trash they got going (no talent at all )!

10. ksmithwilson -
I take that back I am being unfair they are all talented ladies but unfortunatly the media got to me and I feel Beyonce is the STAR!

11. lilslim_nukka89 -
it doesnt matta cause i thank dat everybody in DC is good n Michelle is nothin lyke Beyonce she has more of a baby raz-b type voice dat is so Amazin n Pretty dat she doent need 2 sang a loud as Beyonce n make all of her note roll lyke beyonce is ALWAYZ doin. but dnt get it twisted i lyke B n all

12. soulbrotheris1 -
they all have talent and any should not be discounted. i think solange is approaching it from a diff. angle - neo-soul. unfortunately, it seems that all three will continue to be compared to Beyonce which is also unfair. the key is to look beyond Beyonce - WHAT HAVEN'T SHE DONE - what approach hasn't she taken; she is a power house AND that doesn't mean that Kelly, Michelle or Solange can't bring it! they all have something to offer.

13. ladyxoldie -
I agree with ndidi a that the media publicity is giving to Beyonce is highly overrated. I like Kelly songs from day 1 since going solo and Solange is good too. They don't even get credit for their acting roles and Beyonce seems to get credit for her even in Dream Girls when she was trying to be the superstar in that movie as well. But she could not top Jennifer as all. Her songs are very good but she is so overrated. Again, all she do is bounce her butt 100 different ways and that whats got the public. Leave her butt to Jay-Z the happy groom. Good luck to all the girls and may God Bless them all and not just Beyonce. My hat goes out to all that comparing these ladies to one another.

14. soulbrotheris1 -
beyonce overrated? i dont know:
sing - yes
dance - yes
look good - yes
lyrics - creative
Michelle, Kelly and Solange should consider doing a video featuring no one but themselves, individually - maybe in black in white; try having laid back feel to their projects...

15. misstoya1817 -
All I got to say is that B just made Forbes Top 100 (along with her hubby Jay) and I doubt that any of the other three comparisons will ever reach that with just solo status.

16. lovely -
All they have to do is get from under her daddy and they will be fine. If they continue with him they will never be noticed they are really just the hand me down girls whatever beyonce don't want they hand them down to them which is unfair

17. Karma Eve -
All of these women are strong and have proven they can hold their own. The problem is everyone still wants to see them as a group and continues to compare them to Beyonce.

What if they were never in a group and come out solo from the beginning? Then, how would we all feel about them? What if Beyonce wasn't the "main attraction?"

The key thing is to see them as individuals and give them a chance on their own playing field.

Truth be told, how many of you could do what any of them are doing? They are doing what they are capable of doing at this time, at this moment. Give them a chance. I'm not a big fan of either, but they're doing what they do and quite frankly, they're doing it well!

Erotically Speaking,
Karma Eve

18. JAS C -
I believe the girls has gain a lot money than success....... because with out the love they have for oneanother there would be a history or of greatness....

luv ya gurl jas c

19. mahoaportia -
i love this sisters,their voices keep me awaik

20. juicy lips -
Beyonce has always bin on the spotlight.in destiny'child she used to sing the first verse and during shows and concerts she would b in the middle as if kelly and michelle are proctecting her.its just not fair 4 the others.I know that kelly can sing better than b.
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
Next »
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Lyndsey Parker
14
As Heard On...
by Suzanne Baran
12
Better Living Through MP3
by Ken Micallef
150
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
54
Framed
by John Kordosh
60
GetBack
by Cory Frye
89
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
53
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
238
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
81
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
64
On the Road With JamBase
by Aaron Kayce
24
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
260
Rock's Backpages
by The Goodfoot Posse
79
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
by Chuck Eddy
73
Stop The Presses!
by Billy Altman
19
That's Really Week
by Dave DiMartino
68
The ARTHUR Blog
by Paul Krassner
42
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
6
The Lefsetz Letter
by Bob Lefsetz
213
The MOJO Blog
by Stevie Chick
41
The NME Blog
by Dan Martin
22
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
26
The URB Blog
by Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
299
Video Ga Ga
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
41

Music Blog Archives

October 2008 (6)
September 2008 (7)
August 2008 (4)
July 2008 (4)
June 2008 (5)
May 2008 (2)
April 2008 (1)
March 2008 (2)
February 2008 (2)
January 2008 (2)
December 2007 (2)
November 2007 (2)
October 2007 (2)
September 2007 (4)
August 2007 (3)
July 2007 (5)
Lisa Marie Presley gives birth to twins
AP
Sat Oct 11, 2008 1:38pm PDT
AP - Lisa Marie Presley is a mom again. A publicist says the 40-year-old singer gave birth Tuesday to twin girls, whose names were not released. One baby weighed 5 pounds, 15 ounces and the other came in at 5 pounds…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.