Music Blogs

Alicia Keys Rocks Like Tina, Janet, En Vogue ...

Posted Fri Oct 3, 2008 10:37am PDT by Billy Johnson, Jr. in Hip-Hop Media Training

A blind man could have seen this coming. This being Alicia Keys' foray into rock. Her 2001 debut Songs In A Minor was hip-hop influenced, received five 2002 Grammy Awards and most memorably left then fellow newcomer India.Arie empty handed. (Alright. Give me a second to count to 10. The latter still gets me mad.) However, Alicia has never been content. With each record, she has inched towards even more mainstream success and has prevailed.

Alicia steps outside any boundaries with "Another Way To Die," a song for the soundtrack for Quantum Of Solace, the latest James Bond saga. Teaming with Jack White of The White Stripes and The Raconteurs, they duet with their vocals and musicianship, trading Alicia's cutting piano notes with Jack's revving guitar strokes.

Alicia doesn't sit as comfortably here as she does on last year's No. 1 hit "No One," or previous favorites "You Don't Know My Name" or "Fallin'." But maybe that's because, while her vocals on "Another Way To Die" feel true to her style, they don't easily mesh with the rock fueled track that is clearly more White than Keys. Still, I give her props for re-inventing herself.

Alicia's rock track also calls to mind a few other soulful divas who have ventured outside of rhythm and blues to make rock songs.

Janet Jackson "Black Cat"
Years after Janet had established herself as the queen of dance with groundbreaking videos including "Control," "Pleasure Principle" and "Rhythm Nation," she surprised her audience with "Black Cat." While the song was a complete abandonment from Janet's R&B pop style and is featured on the Rhythm Nation 1814 album, it was a massive success, reaching No. 1 on Billboard's Hot 100 chart.

Rihanna "Shut Up And Drive"
Aside from Madonna, it is hard to pinpoint another female pop artist who has changed her sound as frequently as Rihanna. Her 2005 dancehall debut "Pon de Replay" seemed to foreshadow the direction the Barbados-bred singer would take, but she quickly bucked the expectations by trying on new styles with each release. Following her infectious "Umbrella," Rihanna unleashed her rock heavy "Shut Up And Drive" that sampled Orgy's take on New World Order's "Blue Monday." Rihanna still made the track her own as her light-hearted demeanor gave the song added pop sensibilities.

Ike And Tina Turner "Proud Mary"
No other female soul singer has amassed rock graces as Tina Turner. This opinion is best supported in Ike And Tina Turner's performance of the Creedence Clearwater Revival song "Proud Mary." Tina illuminated the stage with both her electrifying singing and dancing that brought rave reviews for the group's 1970 performance on The Ed Sullivan Show. The song became their biggest hit, reaching No. 4 on the American pop singles chart and earning them the Grammy for Best R&B Vocal Performance For A Duo Or Group.

NQ2C2x0&hl=en&fs=1"NQ2C2x0&hl=en&fs=1"NQ2C2x0&hl=en&fs=1"NQ2C2x0&hl=en&fs=1"NQ2C2x0&hl=en&fs=1"NQ2C2x0&hl=en&fs=1"

En Vogue "Free Your Mind"
It's hard to believe that these four ladies are not mainstays in popular music. Hands down, they possessed the best harmonies of any female vocal group of the ‘90s and delivered a seemingly endless string of huge records for several years. "Free Your Mind" was the song that impressed me the most. In delivering this rock song, Cindy, Maxine, Dawn and Terry got into full character, donning rocker chick hair, make-up and clothes; strutting down a catwalk; performing to a full-fledged rock track and boasting a four-part harmony that wins the praises of industry heavyweights. I attended my first En Vogue concert in July 2006 and they were still on fire even with Rhona performing in place of Dawn.

-Iq2tN0&hl=en&fs=1"-Iq2tN0&hl=en&fs=1"-Iq2tN0&hl=en&fs=1"-Iq2tN0&hl=en&fs=1"-Iq2tN0&hl=en&fs=1"

Ashanti "Only U"
[Raising my right hand ...] My name is Billy and I am a former Ashanti hate-a-holic. Yes, I could not help but give Ashanti credit for her catchy songwriting and choruses, but I was having major problems with her routinely singing off key. I was rooting for Missy-protégé Tweet at the time. But I saw something different in the Murder Inc.'s self-proclaimed Princess Of Hip Hop and Soul when she released "Only U" as the first single from her third album, 2004's Concrete Rose. Even though it samples Club Nouveau's 1986 hit "Why You Treat Me So Bad," producer 7 Aurelius turned this into one smoking hot track. I was the last to think that Ashanti could pull off such an accomplishment, but she did, and nicely.

Mary J. Blige "One"
Musically, Mary J. Blige can do whatever she wants to do. She's recorded with Elton John, Aretha Franklin, George Michael and, uh, U-freaking-2. She received Bono and company's blessing to not only remake their 1992 classic "One," but to record it with the legendary group. Despite my love for MJB, I don't particularly care for this version. However, I flipped out over her U2-influenced track "Come To Me" from last year's Growing Pains album. 

Mariah Carey "Bringin' On The Heartbreak"
Mariah Carey could have nailed this remake of Def Leppard's 1981 song "Bringin' On The Heartbreak." Instead, she sucked most of the rock out of the track, save a couple faint guitar rifts and basic melody. She played it way too safely. But since it is a Def Leppard cover, it would have been wrong to omit the recording from a list of R&B chicks singing rock.

Mariah's decision to convert the song into a more traditional pop ballad probably had a lot to do with it being on her Charmbracelet album. Charmbracelet is the follow up to Glitter. You remember Glitter? The blockbuster combo flop-part soundtrack, part autobiographical film-that prompted her public nervous breakdown and release from Virgin Records? Yeah. Playing it safe with "Bringin' On The Heartbreak" was actually a smart move. Following Glitter, the last thing Mariah needed to do was to screw up a classic. And it worked. Charmbracelet helped Mimi prepare to be Emancipated in time for her next album. After "We Belong Together" she was sitting back in her throne.

40 Comments

1. mis -
MARY J SONG ONE IS GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!! SIT BACK AND CLOSE YOUR EYES AND LISTEN YOU WILL HAVE A WHOLE DIFFERENT VIEW OF THE SONG

2. Julian -
One is one of my favorite rock songs. I coulnd not believe that they went with it. It took time to grow on me too. It s good. When they debuted it liveon the awards show it wasnt that great. Then again when people debut theier songs prior to them coming hits ,they very rarely are good.
Great choices. I do like the Alicia Keys and Jack White oint tho.

3. Aaron -
Alicia keys should stick to rehashing old music, adding new lyrics, and yelling for relevance, because i never want to hear this song again! Their voices sounded like nails on a chalk board. I think Mariah rocked "Bringing on the heartbreak" with those power house vocals! Even Def Leppard was impressed!

4. michael -
Jack White is a GOD, anything he does is cool. As for Keys she'll get the grammy or what ever award for this, cause MTV is so ging to play this one over and over and over again.

5. Trisha -
I loved it!! Alicia has that bluesy thing going on, and I think that there is plenty of room for blues and rock and trying new things!! Good combination here with the White Stripes singer. He may have ovepowered her 'rock' a little, but it wasn't terrible!!
Would love to see her team up with some other rock stars and do more.

You rock on Alicia!! ;)

6. LadyRenaissance -
"Free your mind" was not from the Set It Off soundtrack (you're confusing "Don't Let Go"). "Free Your Mind" came out years earlier on "Funky Divas". GET IT STRAIGHT!

7. Billy J -
LadyRenaissance, thanks for setting me STRAIGHT. I guess I was having Set It Off withdrawls and just wanted to force a tie-in. I have fixed.

8. Kary -
I have grown dis-enchanted with Alicia over this last album. And please, don't get the impression that I'm tring to hate, I wish Alicia as much success as she can get. But as a fan, as a consumer, I wouldn't even illegally download her last album, nor can I even tell you its name. I've tried to listen to this song and can't even get past 30 sec.

As far as The Queen of Hip-Hop/R&B, Ms. Mary J Blige, her music and career are beyond approach. Everything she sings comes from her heart. Her rendition of "One" is so simple and true to the sentiment of the songs nature.

9. Yahoo! Music User -
Janet's Black Cat is still rockin'....She has the heart to rock hard!

10. jessica n -
I love U2, but I don't think that they really need Mary J. Blige on there. People should leave U2 songs alone, because they will never top the original.

11. Kevin B -
C'mon people. Tina has more Rock 'n roll in the word "easy" than the rest of these women had in their entire careers and face it, they weren't even trying to be Rock 'n roll. This performance is more eveidence to support my theory that some of the best RnR came from RnB.

12. FitChick -
Ok I love Alicia Keys but I personally dont think this was the song for her. I think maybe Pink should have got this part. I dont get it at all the chemistry between them in this video doesnt seem real to me.

13. KNA725 -
I wish I could watch the videos the old fashioned way....ON MTV!
MTV is awful programming. Bring back video airplay, pleeeasee. Anyone else agree?

14. NYY -
None of those artists are R&B OR Rock, R&B mixed with rock is Jimi Hendrix, thats what it was, then John Bonham died in 1981, and music hasn't been as good since, in the 70's (btw, i'm in high school, so i'm not some old guy talking about 'back in the day'*) EVERY SONG on an album had to be good, Led Zeppelin went their whole career and only released one bad (regarded by most of their fans/ people who like rock as bad) son, Hot Dog, other than that they were perfect, now a band has 1 single, then 12 songs that are just generic crap.

*FYI: back in the day, it was a wednesday

15. Mark -
How do any of these women "rock?" They're all mainstream pop musicians! They rock about as hard as "Camp Rock." Yawn.

16. Alicia -
I agree with Cheyanne...It is one thing to do rock...but I feel like either she should have been singing or he should have been singing but not both...She looks beautiful in this video though...lol.

17. Mr. Moonwalker PJ -
i think it's always interesting and fresh to hear what R&B artists sound like when they let their pop/rock sides out.

it's great when they take chances and do more than just give you a straightforward R&B album when you can mix it up a bit. there's an audience of people in each genre that likes to see sprinkles of different musical influences.

18. Erica -
I love it because I appreciate all music. She's awesome.

19. Jengf F -
I never liked Alicia Keys voice nor her songs, nor her performance, hair, hats, clothes.... just don't like the her style.... even when she reinvented herself... i just like her to play the piano.... no singing, please no dancing.

20. walter -
i wana see norah jones in that punk band!!
Page:  1 | 2 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Paul Grein
30
As Heard On...
by Lyndsey Parker
48
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
149
Framed
by John Kordosh
123
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
346
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
239
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
338
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Justin Mathews
202
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
126
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
610
Rock's Backpages
by Ben Myers (1999)
199
Stop The Presses!
by Lyndsey Parker
88
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
129
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
92
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
50
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
80
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
533
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
74
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
67

Lil Wayne has hometown farewell show before jail

AP
Tue Dec 29, 2009 6:45am PST

AP - Lil Wayne emerged as a top-selling musician known for his clever wordplay and risque lyrics, but like rappers before him, he's staring down a year behind bars at the peak of his career. The artist returned to his … More »

More Music News