Music Blogs

Is Usher's "Trading Places" Video Disrespectful To His Wife?

Posted Fri Oct 3, 2008 10:24am PDT by Billy Johnson, Jr. in Hip-Hop Media Training

A couple weeks ago, MediaTakeOut alleged that the love scenes in Usher's new video "Trading Places" were so steamy that some of his staffers were upset, claiming that the newly married man had taken it too far.

An unnamed source reportedly described Usher's kisses with the video vixen as "disrespectful" to Tameka Foster, the superstar's wife and mother of his baby boy. Foster is rumored to be pregnant with the couple's second child.

After watching the video directed by Chris Robinson, I'm now clear about what prompted the controversy.

The song lyrics advocate intimate role reversal. Usher is telling his woman that he wants her to take charge romantically.

The video offers endless examples.

Usher and the leading lady enjoy extended romps on a bed, leather sofa and stair case.  There is so little clothing worn in the video that there was no need for a stylist or wardrobe budget.

Usher described the video as "very hot, very forward thinking." "This is kinda wishful thinking for all men," he told MTV, "to have a woman finally take control and compliment us the way we compliment them, whether it is taking us out to dinner or opening up the door."

I wonder if Tameka felt disrespected. I doubt it. I would expect that a woman married to a man whose career is based on the appeal of his six-pack would not be fazed by this part of the job.

This song and video will help bring some attention to Usher's Here I Stand, released in April. The album had been deemed a dud, despite making a solid debut with more than 400,000 album sales.

I bet when Usher performs this song on tour he'll bring a female fan on stage at each venue. His 15-date One Night Stand tour kicks off on November 2 in Atlantic City and wraps on November 25 in Dallas.

The adult subject matter will also give Usher a break from the comparisons to Chris Brown, the young new R&B teen pop dancing machine who stole Usher's formula.

2500 Comments

1. emeka -
well the lover man is enjoying his on his vidoe shot. what can i say. keep it going brother.

2. Robin -
I personally though it was a very hot video, and Usher needed to do something like this to show he is still in the game. I see it as him acting. What is the difference between a music video and a movie? Married actors have love scenes all the time and not with their wives and it is seen as them working. Usher was acting on a smaller scale. If I was Tameka, I would want to jump his bones after seeing that. Usher just set himself apart from the others in the game. I bought my concert ticket yesterday, will be front row center for the show in Chi-town.

3. evans -
WOW, the video is hot. I 100% agree with you shorti, it is a job, and ppl do it all the time in tv shows, movies. I think once again, the news is trying to create something out of nothing. They can if we let them.

4. Yahoo! Music User -
I do agree with the theory that this is just acting and people are probably just trying to make something out of nothing. However, we should also be aware of the fact that people almost always equate music to the artist real lives way more than if it was a movie or tv show. The reason for most of it is beacause most songs that you hear are in some way or another personal to the artist who is singing them. Whether they wrote the songs themselves or it was written based on journals and life experiences. Having said all that, i do understand why people might think that Usher's video was disrespectful to his wife, simply beacause he didn't have to do the scenes that way, the msg could have still been conveyed without all that extra. Cause unlike acting where you're depicting at least 5 other people's visions before anybody gives a damn about you, this video represents Usher and what Usher stand for and what Ushers priciples are. -I'm just sayin'

5. Lady-G -
THATS WONDERFUL THERE IS NOTHING WRONG. IT'S REALY HOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

6. Love Richard -
well,it's nothing,married pple do worst things on love scene so tam shuld allow usher mek money with wat he knows hw to do best,abi dem dey follow blacks jealous too?

7. lovely -
i thought it was a good video and the wife can't trip cause he coming home to her at the end of the day.... and they can trade places...they probably have already lol

8. Yahoo! Music User -
that a gud video, but "what your name" featuring will-i-am need to have a video that song is very hooooooot

9. lala -
i think the video is hotter than ever it shows me thst usher is definitly back since hiring his mother usher is too dame sexy to just stop making videos that his fans want to see him in great job keep up the sexxy.

10. Yahoo! Music User -
I don't care what you all say that video was hot, hot, smoking hot. But I think Usher is starting a new definition of sex appeal and not just have to people go on sex appeal just by his looks. I love the way he is starting a new version of himself so to speak great job and keep the good work.

11. Myron -
I think the video is one of the hottest he has ever made.usher is in a league of his own and there is nothing wrong with that keep up the good work dud, its a smash

12. Abie -
I think what Usher is doing is wrong as he is married. There is nothing sexy he is doing, why cant he do that with his wife?

13. Mya -
I love your video moving mountain

14. Sexy slim -
I personally think the video is disrespectful, to me once an artist gets married, his values and integrity for his wife and family should change the way videos of this matter are done. Don't get me wrong i love usher, but i think family comes first. Now if she doesn't have a problem with it then hey i don't either. But personally if i was in the situation, a singer artist is not the same as an actor or actress, their videos can have what they want in them. The video could have been done with less, kissing and groping, etc......in respect that he is a married man, a christian, and he should have standards for himself and career. Point blank!

15. Yahoo! Music User -
IT'S THE NEW GENERATION, EVERYONE&EVERYTHING IS ALL ABOUT HUGAR!! ALL THERE IS 2 DO IS GO WIT THE FLO!IF IT WAS THE OTHER WAY AROUND IT WOULD BE A LARGER PROBLEM.. BECAUSE WE ARE MORE WATCHED&RESPECTED!!!

16. Yahoo! Music User -
i am a big usher fan and i loved that video,and he has to so his fans that he still got it even though he is married.And if they both are madly in love with each other it should not matter

17. melissa m -
i just wish he'd coem out with a video for This Aint Sex i loooove that song... i love this video though...reminds me of the old usher...the confessions/8701 usher...i wasnt too ecstatic about his new cd here i stand but i am really feeling those few songs including best thing with Jay-Z i will always love usher he's a great entertainer he really goes all out for his fans so i cant knock his hustle i just hope he chose the right woman to understand his career and what he does whole heartedly and not half a$$ed lol keep it up Ush

18. Cinthya -
i love usher...wish i was in the video

19. reginah -
Well i personally think that he should of had his wife in da video because if they filmed this wat if they do more than that off camera???!!!!

20. glorimer -
i don't think there is nothing wrong with usher's style .
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Paul Grein
30
As Heard On...
by Lyndsey Parker
48
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
147
Framed
by John Kordosh
122
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
344
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
237
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
337
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Andy Pemberton
197
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
126
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
607
Rock's Backpages
by Tony Stewart (1977)
197
Stop The Presses!
by Lyndsey Parker
87
That's Really Week
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
128
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by James McNair
91
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
49
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
80
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
529
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
73
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
65

Report: Kevin Jonas, ex-hairdresser marry in NY

AP
Sat Dec 19, 2009 11:27pm PST

AP - A report says the oldest sibling of pop group the Jonas Brothers and a former hairdresser have married at a French-style chateau in suburban New York. People magazine reported a heavy snowstorm bore down on Saturd… More »

More Music News