Music Blogs

Five Breakup Songs

Posted Fri Feb 22, 2008 11:15am PST by Rob O'Connor in List Of The Day
When you just don't have the words to say it...Honey, I'd rather you not be here...it's time to find a song that does it for you. Sometimes love has an expiration date. It's like milk, it goes bad, and much quicker if you don't keep it refrigerated. Sadly, too many of us leave our relationships on the counter overnight and must face the consequences of our negligent actions. If you're one of those people, you might want to consider condensed milk. It stores much longer and is great in emergencies. How this relates to love? I'm no Dr. Phil. I just make the bad analogies and metaphors, I don't solve other people's problems.

"Breaking Us In Two"--Joe Jackson: You can tell this song is sad because the piano sounds like it's dying. Lots of slow, descending notes, the singer sounds tired and the beat never picks up. Nope. This is about how getting it over with never seems to be over with. One of life's annoyances. Like how the towels never seem to dry on the first cycle and always take two, sometimes three tries to get done. Life's tough.

"Never Talking To You Again"--Husker Du: In this song the singer lets us know he's never talking to his boy or girlfriend ever again. Of course, it's arguable that by announcing that he's never talking to him or her again, he's actually talking to him or her, and, therefore, invalidating the sentiment of the song. Which thankfully doesn't invalidate the song because in the end songs don't have to make sense. You just have to be able to hum them.

"Love Will Tear Us Apart"--Joy Division: Ah, whenever you need a little uplift you can always count on those cheery Manchester blokes, Joy Division! Yes, you can hear it in the air tonight, things will be swingingly great! If only love didn't expose one's failings. If only love didn't leave a nasty taste in people's mouth (try Scope! and brush your tongue). If only we could live each day like it was our last, we'd never need to buy a calendar again.

"My Love For You Has Turned To Hate"--Hank Williams: Well, this is a rather blunt way of putting it. Bi-Polar disorder was not always clearly recognized back in the 1950s when Hank Williams was making his way through the country music world, so it was only right of Hank to try and shed light on this often ignored topic and get people talking. Fred Flintstone, it should be noted, was also known for his abrupt mood shifts, his ability to hate Barney Rubble one moment and forsake him for Joe Rockhead only to realize that Barney was his one true pal. Fred could've been a spokesman for bi-polar disorder, but, alas, he is not real.

"The Breakup Song"--Greg Kihn: For a song called "The Breakup Song" and therefore perfect for this column, I don't actually know if this is about any kind of breakup. The only part of the song I know is the "They don't write ‘em like that anymore," which I take to be a complaint about sinking literacy achievements in popular song. To which I'd like to suggest that Mr. Kihn sit down with some fine albums of modern day folksingers where people like Freedy Johnston (remember him?), Shawn Colvin and tons others have if anything overwritten their songs to such a literary degree that you can't even sing them anymore. But then maybe this song is about something else altogether. Who cares? Just hum along with the bum-bum-bum part. It's more fun when you don't have to think.

19 Comments

1. LISA -
Joy Division's "Love Will Tear Us Apart" is perfectly sorrowful and longing at the same time. Excellent choice.

2. babyd -
the breakup song..how perfect

3. Yahoo! Music User -
what about the Nillsson song: "You've broken my heart, you tore it apart so f*** you!"

4. JOHN -
heres some classic baby boomer breakup songs

breaking up is hard to do... Neil Sedaka
without you Nillson
she's leaving home Beatles
caroline no the beach boys
Susan & Kind of a Drag ...the Buckinghams
bye bye love everly brothers
Crying Roy Orbison
(AS you see many of these weren't bitter but more longing to have the person back...Yep times are changing eh!)

5. Bob O -
Yes, the Nilsson song, nice choice.

6. Brian P -
I immediately thought of two songs when I read the article's title:

Liz Phair, "Divorce Song"
Ben Folds Five, "Song for the Dumped"

When I was fifteen and my first girlfriend broke up with me, I listened to Radiohead's "Creep" for two or three hours. Still not sure why. I'm not a creep nor a weirdo, and I was in my room, where certainly I belonged.

7. Noofdawg -
#1 best breakup song ever
"Song for the Dumped" Ben Folds Five

8. some kid -
what about "so happy" by theory of a deadman??

9. Ethan Edwards -
What no H.A.T.R.E.D by Tonio K? which includes the best parting shot of the 1970's " I wish I could be as mellow as for instance Jackson Browne\But fountain of sorrows my a$$ Mo&h#r F&c#er I hope you whined up in the ground"
and you forgot the entire Afghan Whigs catalog!

10. Sarah -
I Will Survive

11. Matthew -
We can have a lot of fun with this list!

Don't Go Away Mad (Just Go Away)/Motley Crue
The Telephone Call/Joe Satriani
Everything About You/Ugly Kid Joe
Better Not Call/Zebra
Love Rears It's Ugly Head/Living Colour
Something I can Never Have/Nine Inch Nails

for starters...

12. Kelsey -
I'm so sick of you by weird al...

13. My own world of Wyrd -
50 Ways to Leave your Lover, by Paul Simon. I'm sorry, but I love that song

14. Jacobo -
One Eight Seven by Senses Fail, even if you don't like their music, the lyrics are something I'll never forget

15. DennyRules -
The most existentially heartbreaking break-up song of all time is, undoubtedly, "Caroline, No" by Brain Wilson & The Beach Boys.

Not to mention the most gorgrous, as well.

16. M -
um.. HELLO!!! PITCRE TO BURN!?!?!?!?! Shoulda said no!!!!!!! COME ON PEPOLE!!! COUNTRY MUSIC IS YOUR FRIEND!!!

17. Yahoo! Music User -
I've been thinking the same.... when you break up country is your friend - before he cheats, taken off this pain, should of said no, etc

18. Kimberly M -
what about "f*uck what I said" by eamon

19. ojibwa60 -
love EM,and I leave EM,the wanderer was my favorite!
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Paul Grein
30
As Heard On...
by Lyndsey Parker
48
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
148
Framed
by John Kordosh
123
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
345
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
238
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
337
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Andy Pemberton
199
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
126
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
609
Rock's Backpages
by Ben Myers (1999)
199
Stop The Presses!
by Lyndsey Parker
88
That's Really Week
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
128
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
92
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
50
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
80
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
532
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
74
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
66

Reports: Aerosmith's Tyler enters rehab

AP
Wed Dec 23, 2009 1:26am PST

AP - Aerosmith front man Steven Tyler says he has entered a rehab clinic to treat an addiction to pain killers he has taken to cope with 10 years of performance injuries. Tyler says in a statement released Tuesday to P… More »

More Music News