Music Blogs

Marching For Emo

Posted Fri May 30, 2008 11:35am PDT by Dan Martin in The NME Blog

The suicide of 13-year-old Hannah Bond was a tragedy, but emo music is not to blame. And tomorrow, an estimated thousand music fans will march on the offices of a U.K. newspaper in an attempt to point that out.

Emo music, and My Chemical Romance in particular, have been under an unpleasant spotlight in the U.K. this month since a depressed teenager from Kent took her own life. And the fact that she was a fan of the genre has been blamed.

The scapegoating of alternative music in the press is nothing new. But what's all the more disturbing about this case is that the coroner singled out the emo genre as playing a part in Hannah's death. Roger Sykes said, "The emo overtones concerning death and associating it with glamour I find very disturbing."

This was all the Daily Mail newspaper needed to revive their crusade against a culture that actually has much more to do with uniting people and sending a message of hope. Nevertheless, they whipped up another editorial about this apparent "suicide cult" designed to panic parents, even going as far as to make inaccurate claims that MCR's "Black Parade" is "a place where all emos believe they go when they die."

http://www.nme.com/news/various-artists/36468

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/femail/article-566481/Why-child-safe-sinister-cult-emo.html

My Chemical Romance spoke up because they had to, sending condolences to Hannah's family, but pointing out that: "My Chemical Romance are and always have been vocally anti-violence and anti-suicide. As a band, we have always made it our missions through our actions to provide comfort, support, and solace to our fans.

"The message and theme of our album The Black Parade is hope and courage. Our lyrics are about finding the strength to keep living through pain and hard times. The last song on our album states, 'I am not afraid to keep on living'--a sentiment that embodies the band's position on hardships we all face as human beings."

The Daily Mail whipping up fear and misunderstanding is nothing new either, but the fans who feel this music has helped them through their problems, not exacerbated them, are not standing for it.

Tomorrow, an estimated thousand fans will march upon the newspaper's London offices, in a show of solidarity, and respect for Hannah. Organizer Anni Smith told NME.com: "The [Daily Mail 's] words 'suicide cult' really stand out for me, because it's just so far from the truth. As a fanbase it's such an insult because we fight so hard and so many of us suffer from depression, and we fight every day to ward it off.

"The way [many teenagers are] fighting it is with My Chemical Romance's help and it's just such an insult to tell us that the last thing we have to hold on to and the last thing that's keeping us alive is killing us, because it's not."

NME.com will be at the march tomorrow.

http://www.nme.com/news/my-chemical-romance/36848

 

146 Comments

81. AaronJ -
music does not make people kill them selves it may give them an idea but it is their choice to act oppon it. the some thing happened with mariyn manson and colombine.

82. Yahoo! Music User -
I too was suicidal at age 13-15, so I'm in understanding of why. I let the stress of the world collapse onto me, mostly my family and school. I was foolish to let it happen to me, and I came extremely close to killing myself, but, music, of any genre, and any influence on my depression, not even "emo" music, whic I used to listen to quite a bit, MCR being one of the main bands I used to listen to. The media and government are always looking for things to blame in situations like this, because they don't want to face the truth and accept that it could have been something as simple as a little stress build-up. My deepest sympathies to the family, and my her soul rest peacefully.

83. chelseae -
This is complete and utter bullcrap music from mcr has never made me want to kill myself it gave me hope to carry on no matter what other kids said about me I thought you english knew better this news paper needs to do some real research ha emo kids think they go to the black parade when they die bullshiz I would never think that wow congrats news papers of england...

84. Roussel H -
first L, I totally agree with you

85. Jazmine S -
Dude,MCR is awsome and as long as i live i will listen!!

86. sean b -
My prayers at to Hannah's family and friends.

87. Kristina -
I am a 31 year old married woman, mother of twin girls, living in Maine...if you fools think that this tragedy has ANYTHING to do with a band or their music you are SADLY MISTAKEN!!!! This has all come up in the past with messages hidden until you played the music in reverse..blah blah blah blah...find something better to do with your time people!!!! A person, as an individual, regardless of what he or she listens to, makes their OWN decisions in life and there are ALWAYS underlying factors that generate these feelings...it has NOTHING TO DO WITH MUSIC, it has to do with life and the way you interpret it.

88. V -
mcr(my chemical romance) dosent have anything to do with the girls death it isnt the bands fault the girl had problems and couldnt take it any more and killed her self.(if i was over there i would probley say that)ps.i am also a fan of mcr(also music any type the person wants to listen to has no reason to do with that persons death it just gives them comfort from the lyrics to stay strong and deal with it)

89. Scooby -
How many more times are we going to do this in America, or now anywhere else? First, it was everyone tryint to blame Marilyn Manson when people were committing suicide. Then, it was everyone blaming Eminem and rap in general for violence between people. Now, the blame's been passed to emo for people committing suicide. How about we just stop placing the blame on music? Everyone needs a release in their life, and most people turn to music. But don't DARE turn that release into a reason for people committing violence or committing suicide. It was their own decision, not a particular artist, group, or genre of music.

90. Yahoo! Music User -
I don't usually respond to blogs, even though I find them entertaining to read, but I am a huge fan of MCR, not only for thier musical talent and way of performing, but of the lyrics they choose to sing. Yes, MCR is part of a genre that many would consider "emo" but thier statement was true when they say that they mean to convey a message of anti-violence and hope. Their song "Teenager"s is just a satire against the stereotypes of high school, and in, "Welcome to the Black Parade" one of the main lines is, "We'll carry on." Not something that would typically make one want to commit suicide. The girl in question was obviously dealing with problems, and didn't know how to handle it. My condolences to her family, as such a tragedy should never occur. However, blaming music is not the answer, especially the "emo" genre, which promotes the release of pent up feelings. Something else caused this girl to take her life, as sad as it is. Music was not the cause, and if I was in London, I would be marching in the streets in protest as well. My Chemical Romance is an amazing band, and I'm sure they are as saddened by this loss of life as most people are.

91. Sarra -
MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE ROCKS AND STUPID TEENS LIKE HER JUST WANT ATTENTION. MY CHEMICAL ROMANCE IS ANTI-SUICIDAL AND IS NOT JUST FOR EMO KIDS. I THINK IF EMO KIDS ARE GOING TO KILL THEM SELFS THEN JUST DO IT AND DONT BLAME IT ON MUSIC OR OTHER PEOPLE. IT IS THEIR STUPID CHOICE.

92. Sarra -
Heather chick u rock because i am totaly on ur side. and yes it is true parents just use that excuse and blame any thing and every thing they can. If any one wants to talk more about this with me then email me @ sarrabear@yahoo.com

93. Koko -
first of all, why do people even have to blame this genre!? if we took time to understand what the bands are trying to do, and trying to convey to their listeners, then we won't have to be all worked up bout this 'emo' thing. and besides, don't they even think that their just doing it for the band's image? dudes, seriously, don't think that they want you to die or sumthing. it's just how the bands want to be seen as who they are and it's up to us to interpret what they're trying to say.

94. M.E.L -
I think I'd probably kill myself too if I had to listen to that emo garbage

95. BeccaSue -
um... that's just retarded... seriously....

96. Janet D -
Yeah, samething happened here in the US in the ear '80's; blaming KISS or Judas Priest and now My Chemical Romance is not a solution.

97. Aliro S -
I cannot even begin to state all the things wrong with this, but this is not the first time the Daily Mail has attacked My Chemical Romance and it probably won't be the last. I admire the UK fans for standing up for their music and for mourning Hannah's loss. I think it's sick when someone decides to take a tragedy like this and twist it around to suit their agenda, which in this case is unclear but just as disgusting. Shame on the Daily Mail, may you be bankrupted by law suits you hacks.

98. chare -
what the eff?? music has nothing to do with this suicidal scene.. first of all emo music is a kind of expression towards music it is not a suicidal music..

99. Yahoo! Music User -
********PLEASE READ THIS*******


Mcr are brilliant and i feel really sorry for them becaquse they dont deserve bad press. The lyrics to each song are meaningful and each word will always mean something different to other people - no one is the same, that is what makes the world so beautiful. If everyone was the same the world would be boring. Emo music is not to blame for one persons' actions. Everyone has bad patches in their life. Most people get thorough them. At the minute, im trying to recover from things too; im doing great. I know people who self-harm. I know that i did. But self harm doesnt help. People need to understand that. I feel really sorry for that girls' parents. It must be hard for them. I don't think that she should have done suicide. I think that someone should have helped her, to listen and have someone to understand you is all that people need sometimes. I know that was all i wanted. I hope people have benifited from my comment and feel much better! If you know someone like me or Hannah, I hope that you can find help for them. People need help! Spread the love xxx See You all x Email me at ericamclure@hotmail.co.uk xxxx ly all x


After all, a song is a song.

100. Marjorie -
I'm glad that people are actually protesting against this. I can't believe that people would go as far as to say that any music, regardless of genre or other things, is the cause of someone committing suicide. You don't just commit suicide because you hear a so-called "emo" song. It doesn't work that way. She committed suicide because of whatever going on in her life, not because of My Chemical Romance, or any other band. Like they said, and others on here have said, My Chemical Romance isn't even about death. Their message is a way more positive one, trying to prevent things like this from happening. Don't blame the music, people. And thank you to everyone who is London protesting this. You're doing a good thing!!
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Paul Grein
30
As Heard On...
by Lyndsey Parker
48
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
150
Framed
by John Kordosh
123
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
346
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
239
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
339
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Justin Mathews
204
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
126
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
613
Rock's Backpages
by Nick Hasted (2003)
200
Stop The Presses!
by Lyndsey Parker
88
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
130
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by Bill DeMain
92
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
50
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
80
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
533
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
74
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
68

Correction: Van Morrison story

AP
Thu Dec 31, 2009 6:19pm PST

AP - In a Dec. 28 story, The Associated Press, relying on information from Van Morrison's Hollywood-based publicist and his official Web site, reported erroneously that the Irish singer had a new baby boy with a woman id… More »

More Music News