Music Blogs

Giving Thanks To Canadian Rock

Posted Mon Oct 13, 2008 11:18am PDT by David Marchese in The Spin Blog

Happy Canadian Thanksgiving! Yep, our hockey and Tragically Hip-loving neighbors to the north celebrate turkey day too. Seeing as how Thanksgiving is such a prominent day on the American calendar, it's a little goofy to think that Canadians also annually sit down to a meal where both stuffing and cranberry sauce figure prominently, but hey, there's plenty of both to go around. So in the spirit of giving thanks, I've listed my ten favorite Canadian pop/rock acts. You won't find Nelly Furtado, Alanis Morrissette, Feist, the New Pornographers or Bryan Adams on this list, but if you think they, or any other Can-rock stars, deserve mention, make sure to say so in the comments section.

1. Neil Young: In terms of longevity, popularity, influence, and talent, only Joni Mitchell comes close as a Canadian rock legend.

2. The Guess Who: There's way more to Winnipeg's favorite sons than "American Woman." Like, for example, rock's best ever Prairie province shout-out (on 1972's "Running Back To Saskatoon.")

3. Willie P. Bennett: The most obscure musician on this list. The Toronto-born Bennett passed away in February, but left behind a catalogue of musically sparse, emotionally rich country folk.

4. Destroyer: A part-time member of the New Pornographers, Vancouverite Dan Bejar's shambling, Bowie-esque guitar jams and densely-packed lyrics reach full fruition on the albums he records under the Destroyer moniker.

5. Broken Social Scene: 2002's You Forgot It In People is a modern classic and helped shepherd in the era of multi-member indie collectives. But aside from being influential, the Toronto-based BSS also kicks ass--in a distinctly ethereal way.

6. Leonard Cohen: "Hallelujah" alone would have earned Cohen a place on this list. So would "Bird On A Wire"; "Suzanne"; "Tower Of Song"; "I'm Your Man"; etc.

7. Tegan & Sara: Jack and Meg White have good taste. Hence, the White Stripes covered this Calgary folk duo's "Walking with a Ghost" on a 2005 EP. A band with really good taste should cover "Back in Your Head," from the Tegan & Sara's 2007 album The Con.

8. Joni Mitchell: I haven't loved her late-career forays into more impressionistic material, but Alberta's Mitchell had about a 10-year run from the late-‘60s to late-‘70s that's pretty much beyond reproach.

9. Rush: More than 30 years after forming, this virtuosic trio can still compel arenas full of dudes to air drum along to multi-part epics about the temple of Syrinx, By-Tor and the Snow Dog, and Tom Sawyer.

10. Voivod: French Canada deserves representation, and these metal lifers are Quebec's best heavy music act. Check out 1989's Nothingface for a blast of proggy and melodic thrashing.

See more Spin at www.spin.com

23 Comments

1. Kevin -
If Joni Mitchell is the only one who comes clotose to neil young then why is neil number 1 and Joni is number 8?

2. phyllis b -
What no BNL?

3. phyllis b -
What no BNL?

4. Michael -
where's Barenaked Ladies on this list?

5. __A_YAHOO_USER__ -
Haha @ yahoo music user. But good list. It vaugely reminds me of a guy wiht a totally wicked beard and a name that begins with R.

6. Yahoo! Music User -
one of my favorite acts is rocker kim mitchell .still going strong after 30+years.keep on rockin'. from s.a. texas

7. Corbin -
no nickelback?

8. phillyfan -
Once again, he proves he knows absolutely NOTHING about music. Only 3 of the artists I would consider the cream of Canadian rock. Neil Young, Rush (second only due to Neil's longevity but first in my book for sheer musicianship), and The Guess Who. You forgot to mention such acts as BNL, Nickleback (more pop than rock now, but started out as such), Our Lady Peace, Bachman Turner Overdrive, Loverboy (they were rock when they started but morphed into a monstrocity thanks to 80s 'influences'), and the list goes on and on. You really need to do your research pal. Some of the artists on here I never even heard of.

9. DUDE -
I noticed that Nickleback did not make the list.The reason is that they suck.

10. lets make believe -
ARCADE FIREEE!!!

11. Yahoo! Music User -
bedouin soundclash

12. JD -
what about billy talent?

13. Matthew Q -
propagandhi is the best canadian band ever eehh!

14. jeff -
Rush should be at the top of this list for many reasons. The only reason that they are not is that they do not fit the formula for commercial radio. In terms of pure talent and success at drawing and keeping a dedicated fan base and overall sales recipts, these guys blow the rest out of the water!

15. Timothy M -
no Bryan Adams? Alanis Morrissette? Finger eleven? BNL?

no offense intended, but WTF

16. WilliamA -
Barenaked Ladies could be on there. Not a big deal. Tragically Hip should be on there. The list is your opinion. I understand. You need to understand that in Canada the Hip are beloved. They can't be left off a list that is as specific as the best that rock in Canada, because they are the best almost anywhere. (Otherwise, nice job. Just be aware next time.)

17. Lyndsey Parker -
David, where is Sloan??? and The Pursuit Of Happiness? And Arcade Fire?

18. Spencer -
Where did finger eleven, bryan adams, nickleback, and avril lavigne go?

19. Linda -
I can't believe that Sloan and Arcade Fire were left off!
And what about classic rockers like Bachman-Turner Overdrive and Tom Cochrane???

20. __A_YAHOO_USER__ -
To Spencer, and phyllifan just cuz you havent heard of them doesnt mean they suck, and finger 11 is average. Nothing special about them, and nickelback is about as generic as post-grunge gets.
Page:  1 | 2 
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Paul Grein
30
As Heard On...
by Lyndsey Parker
48
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
145
Framed
by John Kordosh
122
GetBack
by Shawn Amos
340
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
233
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
334
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
167
Musictoob
by Andy Pemberton
193
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
125
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
599
Rock's Backpages
by Ron Ross (1975)
195
Stop The Presses!
by Lyndsey Parker
87
That's Really Week
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
127
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
27
The MOJO Blog
by James McNair
91
The NME Blog
by Luke Lewis
49
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
80
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
523
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
71
Viva NashVegas
by Wendy Geller
64

Kanye, Tiger, the Gosselins — our unfortunate 2009

AP
Mon Dec 14, 2009 5:29pm PST

AP - If only there were more Kanye Wests in the world. No wait — lemme finish!! Yes, West proved he was a complete jerk when he jumped onstage and interrupted Taylor Swift's glory moment at the MTV Video Music Aw… More »

More Music News