Jan. 14-21: Britney Vs. Christina--The Rematch

Posted Thu Jan 17, 2008 2:54pm PST by Lyndsey Parker in That's Really Week

Hey, remember how only a few years ago, "Britney vs. Christina" was the big headline-making feud in pop? We sure do, and honestly, if we'd had to predict back then which of the two Mouseketeers-turned-babydivas was going to grow up to be the very model of marital bliss and motherhood, and which was going to end up a head-shaving, underwear-forgetting, paparazzi-baiting hot mess...well, quite frankly, our vote would've gone to the artist formerly known as Xtina.

See, back then, sweet little Britney Spears was still espousing virginity (it's hard to believe now that her 2003 confession to W magazine, that she'd made the sexyback with two beasts with then-boyfriend Justin Timberlake, actually qualified as SHOCKING news at the time) and doing yoga with then-BFF Madonna.

Meanwhile, Christina Aguilera was dressing like Dee Snider of Twisted Sister, bathing in vats of neon-orange self-tanner, piercing every spare inch of her orange-tanned flesh with 10-gauge surgical steel, collaborating with Lil' Kim, getting dirrty in some of the most skanktastic music videos ever made, and surfacing in raunchy rumors about alleged affairs with Carson Daly and Fred Durst.

So who could blame us for assuming that Christina (the more talented but seemingly more troubled of the two) was on a Promises-bound downward spiral, while Britney's career had nowhere to go but up, up, up?

Well, obviously a whole lot's changed since then. Maybe, just maybe, these girls' fates were sealed by their choices in husbands.

See, Christina married the sane, successful music-biz mogul Jordan Bratman (subject of "Ain't No Other Man," and the knight in shining Armani armor that she has frequently referred to as her savior, her rock, her hero). Christina subsequently reinvented herself as a retro torch singer, complete with a classy '40s-pinup makeover and mature jazzy sound. And this week, she further reinvented herself as a mommy, happily giving birth to her first child, Max Liron Bratman. And we've got a feeling Max is going to grow up in a much stabler environment than Britney's poor little tykes, Sean Preston and Jayden James.

Anyhoo, as everyone INCLUDING people who've been living in caves know by now, Britney went down a very different, much rockier marital road. First she quickie-wed Jason Alexander in Vegas, then she tied the knot with "rapper" Kevin Federline. She and K-Fed made an unwatchable reality show about their doomed love, Chaotic, mostly shot on a nightvision camcorder; she quickly popped out two babies and then almost as quickly lost interest in them; she filed for divorce from K-Fed; and then things REALLY downward-spiraled from there, as has been detailed in this very blog over the past year.

We can only wonder what might have happened if, in some alternate pop universe, Christina had married one of her backup dancers and Britney had married a nice young exec at her record label instead. But we'll never know. All we can do is offer congratulations to Christina and our continued prayers to Britney.

Oh, and while we're at it, congratulations are also in order for Nicole Richie--who this week gave birth to daughter Harlow, her first child with her rocker boyfriend, Good Charlotte's Joel Madden. We're just hoping that Nicole, who's had her own troubled tabloid past, follows Christina's example instead of Britney's. We suggest that she schedule some playdates for Harlow and Max, pronto.

And on the pregnancy/baby subject (but on a much, much sadder note), our hearts and condolences go out to Lily Allen. The British pop starlet announced only last month that she was expecting her first child with her boyfriend, Ed Simons of the Chemical Brothers, but now she's confirmed that she is in a "state of shock" after suffering a miscarriage. Very sad stuff. We hope this grieving couple will be able to "Smile" once again soon.

In other news, one diva who's managed to combine Christina's supreme lung-power, Lily's London sassiness, and Britney's career-suicidal (or just plain suicidal) ways into one tiny, trackmarked package is Amy Winehouse. And now it seems Amy's own relationship, with currently incarcerated husband Blake Fielder-Civil (Britain's answer to K-Fed, hence our clever nickname "UK-Fed") may be on the rocks. Rumors are circulating that she is having an affair with her superstar producer Mark Ronson (and, perhaps equally distressingly, that she and Mark are collaborating on a Hannukah album for the 2008 holiday season), but we're wondering if her horrendous new bleach job has anything to do with Blake's reported request for a separation. Seriously, blonde is not a good look for Amy; she'd actually be better off shaving HER head. Anyway, Amy's clearly a major talent, so we're hoping that she can turn her life around like Christina did. Maybe Amy ought to say yes, yes, yes to rehab already.

And finally, while certain overzealous photographers are getting arrested for their hot pursuit of Britney Spears, another crazy-kooky diva is taking paparazzi matters into her own hands: Bjork allegedly attacked a New Zealand shutterbug at the Auckland Airport last weekend, and it's not the first such incident for the swan-dressed Icelandic eccentric. (In 1996, the "Army Of Me" singer launched a one-woman battle against a reporter who attempted to interview her son at an airport in Thailand.) But hey, it could have been worse: At least Bjork didn't use an umbrella in her attack!

And thus concludes another wild, weird week in music. Do come back next Friday for more headspinning headlines (chances are Britney and Amy's names will be among them)...and until then, goodnight, and good music.

  

THIS WEEK'S TOP 10 STORIES:

1) They Want A Piece Of Her - Four photographers are arrested for reckless driving after a late-night car chase with Britney Spears.

2) What A Mom Wants - Christina Aguilera gives birth to a healthy baby boy.

3) Amy Winehouse's Marriage In Need Of Rehab? - Divorce rumors swirl around the troubled star.

4) The Search For The Next Sanjaya Begins - American Idol kicks off its seventh season.

5) Really "Big" Hitmakers - Mary J. Blige, 50 Cent, Timbaland, and Wyclef Jean are implicated in an ongoing steroid investigation.

6) Nicole Richie & Joel Madden's Life Now A Little Less Simple - They've become parents for the first time.

7) Lily Allen Suffers Miscarriage - The 22-year-old songbird is devastated by her loss.

8) Read Without Prejudice - George Michael inks a $7 million book deal to pen his memoirs.

9) No More "I Love You's" For Annie Lennox & Her Label? - The ex-Eurythmics star claims Sony won't return her calls.

10) It's Oh So Violent - Bjork attacks a photographer in New Zealand.

515 Comments

1. benigrad -
Where real talent is concerned, Amy Winehouse has them all licked. I pray that she gets healthy and surrounds herself with positive people. Once whe gets well, her beauty will show.

2. cce9178 -
Dear customer:
How are you? Iam listion that is goog
partty.

3. Yahoo! Music User -
what the hell!!!

4. Michelle -
Did they really use the words "Amy's clearly a major talent"?!?!?!?!?!?!? Has the author actually HEARD her 'sing' (and I use the term very, very loosely). Christina can sing. Mariah can sing. Mandy Moore can sing. Diana Ross... you get my point. If this is the future of music - I'll opt out now.

5. Alex W -
PENIS!

6. my2sense -
I swear if I ever met Lyndsey Parker the two of us would probably be best buddies. We think SO alike!
I totally agree with the Britney & Christina thing, infact I had just been talking about it again. Remember the days when everyone just LOVED lil Brit and basically dissed Christina? I had always loved Christina (although must admit question her fashion sense @ times) But let's face it the girl had/has talent FOR DAYS!!!
I'm just eating it up as Christina emerges as the wonderful artist who is classy and seemingly very happy and well adjusted.
Makes me want to shout it from the rooftops "Told you so!!!Now what?"

7. tatytatertot@sbcglobal.net -
christina is and will always be better than britt.
but anyways i think that they should give Britt a break it doesnt help by having people come after her all the time she needs a break a loooong break and for people to pray for her to get better

8. Yahoo! Music User -
Why brintey be so stupid to do that ....... weird

9. babygrose07 -
Even though brittany spears lost her kids she'll get them back she is not a bad mother.

10. elcalderongrl -
we all kno tht christina was way better from the beginning "even though i use to like brit"...anyways, christina was doing her, imean they probably use to be good friends but u kno its two different artists trying to give out the most albums for a reason: "us fans"...then everything started changing but not for christina a. because she changed her whole style nd coming out GREAT! britney started going down hill she definitly changed her self/style! she was soo good/pretty, now look at her "people making fun of her". mhmmm not good! i love christina a. to death "i actually do want to meet her" shes ecuadorian, i am also. she keeps getting better and better by day after day and enjoys doing it, thats a real CELEBRITY, just like a regular person. i hope she keeps it up!

11. Yahoo! Music User -
this video makes me feel like a end to the world.

12. jazzbooksfood -
Reading this column is like seeing a train wreck: you don't really want to look, but you can't not look.

13. twolow -
o diz iz a good video

14. Yahoo! Music User -
look where they r 2 day!!!

15. Yahoo! Music User -
Wow! That video was the worst thing I've ever seen/heard.
And I agree that the paparazzi just need to leave Britney alone and maybe she'd be less stressed and all that jazz. Everyone needs some personal time, including celebrities.

16. yady -
This is so true. I always loved Christina and I'm glad she's Happy and doing good. But I feel sorry 4 britney and pray that she gets better!

17. babybobo009 -
i hate britney she is a slobe

18. baby_angel_girl_1 -
i just hope that britney makes a comback because i really dont like christina!!!! ive always preferred britney!!! go britney

19. Diane -
leaving britney alone sounds good, BUT i don't think it will happen. the woman seems to want to get people's attention. with her sister's pregnancy, britney is so not wanting to lose the spotlight. i believe that's why she keeps doing all these weird things. i just wish she would realize that the attention would be more positive if she was behaving well. i think she has something missing in her life. she doesn't know what it is and she's looking for it. i think she's looking in the wrong places, but we all know that you can't find the right way the first time every time. i just hope she finds the right path soon. i will pray for her, that the lord will bring her life to the fruition it deserves for her sake and for the sake of her children, too. they need their mom.

20. montanapuppies -
love britney i fell really bad though she has gone through too much!!!!!!!!!!!!!!1
Page:  1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 9 
Next »
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Lyndsey Parker
12
As Heard On...
by Suzanne Baran
10
Better Living Through MP3
by Ken Micallef
139
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
46
Framed
by John Kordosh
55
GetBack
by Matthew Sweet
61
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
40
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
229
Maximum Performance
by Suzanne Baran
76
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
58
On the Road With JamBase
by Aaron Kayce
22
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
244
Rock's Backpages
by Sylvie Simmons
66
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
by Chuck Eddy
43
Stop The Presses!
by Billy Altman
6
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
62
The ARTHUR Blog
by Paul Krassner
35
The Lefsetz Letter
by Bob Lefsetz
184
The MOJO Blog
by Lois Wilson
40
The NME Blog
by Dan Martin
21
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
20
The URB Blog
by Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
274
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
34

Music Blog Archives

August 2008 (5)
July 2008 (4)
June 2008 (4)
May 2008 (5)
April 2008 (4)
March 2008 (4)
February 2008 (5)
January 2008 (4)
December 2007 (4)
November 2007 (5)
October 2007 (4)
September 2007 (4)
August 2007 (5)
July 2007 (5)
Diddy halts private jet flights over fuel prices
AP
Fri Aug 29, 2008 6:29pm PDT
AP - Fuel prices have grounded an unexpected frequent-flyer: Diddy. Sean "Diddy" Combs complained about the "... too high" price of gas and pleaded for free oil from his "Saudi Arabia brothers…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.