Madonna/GTA IV

Posted Fri May 9, 2008 5:07am PDT by Bob Lefsetz in The Lefsetz Letter
Last week at Musexpo, Tommy Nast asked me what my problem was with Clive Davis, why I spare no words in pointing out his faults.

IT'S BECAUSE HE DIDN'T GET MY PERMISSION!

Do you read Seth Godin? Are you aware of "permission marketing"? To boil it down, we're overwhelmed with marketing messages that we don't believe, if you want to sell something to somebody you must have an ongoing relationship with them, you must have their PERMISSION to contact/interact with them.

Let me explain this to you in a language you can understand.

SPAM!

How much do you hate spam e-mail? Who are these jerks who invade your inbox every day, wasting your time. Selling Megad*k and asking you to front money for some dethroned African prince.

You're not calm about spam... You want these guys STOPPED! You want them put in JAIL! You want your inbox to be CLEAN!

Clive Davis has been spamming my inbox. Everywhere I go, from trade publications to Rolling Stone to television this septuagenarian is telling me how great he and his acts are.

Hate to tell you Clive, I NEVER thought Whitney Houston was that great. Might have had a slight desire to sleep with her for a minute or two before she hooked up with Bobby Brown and became a cokehead, but if her music comes on the radio, if I'm exposed to it ANYWHERE, I TURN IT OFF!

God, I'm trying to think of ONE ACT YOU SIGNED AT ARISTA OR J that doesn't make me sick, that I'm not overloaded on, that I haven't had too much of.

Even poor little Alicia Keys. You know, the one who successfully ripped off that James Brown track to make her mark so she could continue to drop forgettable music into the marketplace. She's friendly, she's nice... SO WHY DO I HAVE TO SEE HER ON EVERY AWARDS SHOW! Why do I have to see her change outfits. Why does she need a retinue of backup support. I thought it was about the MUSIC! And the more I'm exposed to her, the more I'm convinced, SHE'S NOT THAT GOOD! I went from mild fandom to indifference to HATE, all because of Clive Davis' overexposure.

Clive... Did you sign the Beatles? The Stones? Nirvana? Radiohead? Is your catalog the most valuable in the business? NO! SO SHUT UP!

Same deal with you Madonna. Like you haven't got enough money. It's no longer about the music with you, it's solely about the fame. You need to be dead center, in everybody's line of sight, getting their attention. You want us to believe you're 25 when you're almost 50. You buy an insurance policy, otherwise known as Timbaland and Justin Timberlake, just so the little kids will pay attention. This ain't music, this is COMMERCE!

And I've got to see you on the cover of Vanity Fair. You've got to hype your movie. Do these mini-concerts where you lip-synch to your music for a fawning press. Do you REALLY THINK WE CARE??

I admired you Madonna... For being a brilliant businesswoman. Now, you're as desperate as a kingpin at Bear Stearns. You don't want to be thrown on the scrapheap. And what you're producing is as lightweight and forgettable as all of Clive Davis' productions.

You sold 280,000 albums the first week out in America. WHOOPEE!! Let's see... That means...ALMOST NOBODY CARES ABOUT YOU! You got a facelift, you worked out for hours a day, you paraded yourself almost naked in every medium known to man, everyone knows who you are, AND ALMOST NO ONE WANTS YOUR MUSIC!

This isn't some stealth project. Something nobody knows about. EVERYBODY knows about Madonna, and most of the public is giving a shrug, they just don't care.

I'm pissed not only at Madonna, but a complicit press so out of touch with what the public wants to read, wants to hear musically. You wonder why papers are tanking. They're out of touch with the American populace. What these sales numbers indicate is ALMOST NO ONE WANTS MADONNA ANYMORE! It's like GM introducing a new SUV and only selling 10,000. WHOOPS! Sure, that's a real figure, but was it worth all the R&D? Didn't GM watch the Japanese, take into account the spiraling price of gas?

You don't give GM a pass, so why do you give the press a pass?

There's a gulf between the press and the public wide enough to sail the Titanic.

That's what we've got today. A desperate industry trying to sell product the same way Tommy Mottola did 15 years ago, by forcing it down our throats.

Meanwhile, Grand Theft Auto IV rakes in 500 million in a week. Could that be because IT'S COOL? It's got a slight underground FEEL?

Think about that, not everyone can partake. Won't play on a Wii, you've got to have a new Playstation or Xbox. That leaves MOST PEOPLE OUT! And it ain't cheap... $60 for the game, never mind what you paid for the console.

Does it seem like the glory days of rock and roll to you? When kids HAD to buy the new Zeppelin album, HAD to see them in concert, when you COULDN'T GET A TICKET?

Zeppelin wasn't all over the news, but they sold millions of records. And they weren't the only ones.

Enough with your corporate tie-ins, your endorsements. You don't belong to the fans, you belong to the BUSINESS! It's ONLY about the bucks. And it doesn't matter what I think, even the little kids know. They know there's more truth in GTA IV than Hard Candy. And they're voting with their dollars. If you think they're dumb...

So, stop dunning me. Try building a RELATIONSHIP with me. Do something great. Let me hear about it from someone else. Let me come to your site. Let me join. Instead of telling me how great you are and that I need to pay attention.

My time is precious, and you're wasting it, blocking my view, preventing me from doing what I WANT TO!

10 Comments

1. hickswinkle1 -
Bob,
Lame. Enough said.

2. brian_fortin -
Hey Man, I almost never take the time to leave comments online, but I feel I must. I applaud your rant and feel the same way. I see Madona, JT, Beyonce, all those Boy Bands, Britney, etc...and all I can think is who listens to this mass produced vanilla flavored music?!...who are these people that buy up this corporately created "paint by numbers" filler? I don't know anyone that owns a CD by any of these peole and will actually come out and admit it or rant about how great their music is....so why do I have to see it plastered everywhere I go?! I can never understand how they get so much exposure, fame and money. I guess the answer is, it's all a business, etc...The good news is, it makes the "non-mainstream" music all that much more interesting.

Brian

3. darin b -
As someone who attended Madonnas Roseland NYC mini-concert...I assure you...she did not lip synch a single word. At least have your facts together before writing such scathing article.

4. Taylor D -
Sounds like a bitter queen to me...LOL. Truthfully, if I looked like you I wouldnt go around criticising others. Madonna is an ICON-25+years. Fat tards like you make us all sick!

5. DUSK -
yeah and i'll waste it some more.

6. Bird started it all -
critics...

7. darin b -
Yeah...and I also love that Bob claims no one cares about Madonna anymore because she "only" sold 280,000 copies of Hard Candy in its first week. Well, it is the #1 album...not just in the US but the world over (#1 in 27 countries)...and 4 minutes has been the #1 digital download. So I guess whatever shes doing, she is still relevent. Just two years ago she sold 8 million copies of "Confessions on a Dance Floor"...and I am sure she will do it again this time around.

8. Todd Rimes -
I clicked through to this post because I'm interested in what people have to say about Madonna, good and bad. I am now leaving this post because I felt like I was being yelled at.

Dude, you need to get a life. And some lithium.

9. Ross Y -
hey want you tailk about

10. E B -
Wow, Bob Letsetz is a bitter person. Madonna's album is still in the top 15 after 7 weeks. Did it sell a lot? NO! That's because albums just don't sell a lot of copies anymore. Her tour, by the way, is doing great numbers.
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Wendy Geller
11
As Heard On...
by Suzanne Baran
7
Better Living Through MP3
by Ken Micallef
128
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
38
Framed
by John Kordosh
50
GetBack
by Cory Frye
28
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
35
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
219
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
66
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
53
On the Road With JamBase
by Aaron Kayce
21
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
201
Rock's Backpages
by Rod Tootell
55
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
by Chuck Eddy
14
That's Really Week
by Lyndsey Parker
56
The ARTHUR Blog
by Paul Krassner
32
The Lefsetz Letter
by Bob Lefsetz
155
The MOJO Blog
by Kris Needs
39
The NME Blog
by Dan Martin
20
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
14
The URB Blog
by Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
247
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
17

Music Blog Archives

July 2008 (15)
June 2008 (23)
May 2008 (37)
April 2008 (25)
March 2008 (22)
February 2008 (31)
January 2008 (2)
Rapper DMX arrested at Phoenix mall
AP
Sat Jul 19, 2008 11:35pm PDT
AP - PHOENIX (AP) — Rapper DMX was arrested at a Phoenix mall Saturday on suspicion that he gave a gave a false name and Social Security number to a hospital to get out of paying for medical expenses. Maricopa…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.