Mariah Madness

Posted Wed Apr 23, 2008 5:00pm PDT by Bob Lefsetz in The Lefsetz Letter
I challenge you to sing three of her songs. Hell, I challenge you to NAME three of her songs!

Let's see... There's "Vision Of Love," a teenager demonstrating melisma for all to see, unleashing upon us countless copycats with vocal training, but no ability to write meaningful music. Then there was "We Belong Together"... Histrionics on steroids, if that concept is even possible. Then... There was that video of her being a bad girl in the bathroom, directed by Brett Ratner. And the one of her on the roller coaster. Oh yeah, and the one of her shaking her mini-tits, before she got that porn star boob job, in the school hall. But what were those records again? And what were the verses of "Vision Of Love" and "We Belong Together"? In both cases I can only remember the single line from the chorus.

Hell, I'm no Elvis fan. But rather than tote up the reasons why he's no match for the Beatles, I'll tell you I can sing UMPTEEN of his hits. From "Hound Dog" to "Suspicious Minds." Maybe because they're classic songs, hits no matter who might have done them. Maybe because I was subjected to many on Top Forty radio again and again. To say that Mariah has eclipsed Elvis' string of number one hits is akin to saying that some quarterback playing Arena football has got a better passing record than Dan Marino... THAT'S RIGHT, THEY'RE DIFFERENT LEAGUES!

Elvis was competing against everybody, when the whole world was watching.

The whole world isn't even listening to music anymore. Hell, there are hundreds of cable channels and multiple video games with a greater visceral effect than ANY of Mariah's hits. Music counted because that's where the innovation was, that's where the flavor was. What exactly is Mariah Carey saying? I'm an uneducated twit who loves junk food who must be supported by the public because I demand so?

And we've got a mainstream media lapping this stuff up. Hyping Mariah like someone cares. Well, SOMEONE does, but not many. She's a sideshow for those lost in the twentieth century.

Not only are many not paying attention to music, a great percentage of those who do ARE NOT LISTENING TO TOP FORTY RADIO!

That's the only place Mariah counts. It's like she's the star shotmaker on an NHL team. Interesting if you're into hockey, but most people DON'T CARE! Saying 500,000 people bought her record the first week out is like saying 1 in 600 people voted in an election... HUH? That's how few care about Mariah. In a country of 300 million, she doesn't mean DIDDLY SQUAT!

But that's the main asset a major label has today. Its media relationships. With favors traded for years, labels can count on a sycophantic media wined and dined into pledging fealty to run nincompoops like Mariah Carey up the flagpole. Come on, her album is a train-wreck. It's like having Quincy Jones, Trent Reznor and Tiny Tim make a record. It's like having the body of an Aston Martin powered by a four-banger with a manual transmission out of a Ford Focus. E=MC2 isn't a record, it's a PRODUCT, constructed by an industry that's lost touch with what the consumer desires. People don't want flash, they want SUBSTANCE! Something meaningful, that they can sink their teeth into.

Enough with the lowest common denominator tripe. Didn't we learn that a great percentage of the public is fed up in last week's debate? I mean if they're booing at a debate, what do you think they'd do if Mariah Carey took the stage? Laugh? Leave? No one who is not a fan gives a crap. And we're lucky, she's running for President of a club we're barely aware of, that we don't have to pay attention to.

Ooh... In an era when the Raconteurs and Elvis Costello release instant albums, sans endless hype, we've got a paint by numbers album massaged into nothing over YEARS marketed for months so that a big first week SoundScan number will be achieved. If this is the game you're playing, I hope no one is watching your expense reports, that you've got a blank check. Because you're wasting tons of money on one act who's only as good as her last record. Yup, Mariah is one stiff away from playing theatres, at best. Hell, she doesn't kill on the road, she doesn't play ten arena dates in one town, that's the classic rock acts. And, don't tell me it's apples and oranges, she's constantly comparing herself to Elvis and the Beatles, but the Eagles can do ten times her live business, and they didn't even have TEN number one singles, never mind the twenty Mariah's going to achieve to become BIGGER THAN THE BEATLES!

But when the Eagles reigned the first time, it was about the album, about FM, about the MUSIC! The trappings were close to insignificant. Band made record, then raped and pillaged on the road, little girls sacrificing their virginity to musicians who wrote songs that changed their lives. If you want one night with Mariah, based on the vapid music she's released, then you must not be married, you must only visit prostitutes, because you're not CAPABLE OF HAVING A MEANINGFUL CONVERSATION, the underpinning of a great relationship!

Mariah is a cartoon. But she's no match for Veronica. And she's certainly no Betty.

But I don't read comic books anymore. Oh sure, there's a Comic-Con, but it's easy to ignore. Just like Mariah Carey and her music.

19 Comments

1. noplayerhaterhere -
Leave my Mariah alone, at least she has more hair than YOU........................

2. Mr. 1 -
Vision of Love
Hero
One Sweet Day
We Belong Together.......all CLASSICS!!!

3. Mr. 1 -
Get your facts stright.
Elvis wasnt competing against everybody, he was ripping off everybody(mostly african-american artist) and shocking and being controversial to the rest( his famous pelvic thrust were banned alot of places).
At least Mariah wrote ALL her #1 hits, something Elvis never did. REGARDLESS if you like them or think they have any "substance"...here's a clue. YOU DONT MATTER!!!!!!! LOL

4. Tamara B -
Whom ever wrote this article can kiss some a$$

5. Tamara B -
Whom ever wrote this article can kiss some a$$

6. naughty -
MARIAH CAREY?.........great, perfectly ladilicious,superWOMAN.

7. naughty -
wonderfull...................

8. Frank T -
I agree with this article totally, I mean look at the responses it has recieved. Not one of the Mariah Carey "fans" has any sort of real arguement against it. He is not jealous, he is simply stating the obvious. Does any of these Carey "fans" remember Glitter?? She is only popular now because people have become "American Idolized" and they accept a lounge act as amazing.

Great article..Mariah Carey bigger than the BEATLES?? John and George are for sure rolling in the graves laughing at this one.

9. mcfan0937 -
Mariah is the best singer ever!!! The person who wrote this is justhiding the fact that they like her music everyone makes mistakes so she made a bad movie who cares

10. Yahoo! Music User -
Allright, the Beatles actually broke boundaries when it came to popular music. Come on, try to counter-argue that.

I agree with this article.

11. gbpackerfan_1999 -
What boundaries did the Beatles break? Please tell me that. The only thing I learned from the Beatles is that the British have nothing good to offer and SImon Cowell keeps proving that point.

12. gbpackerfan_1999 -
No one can top Mariah in singing. No one. The Beatles could not hold a tune to save their lives. They were a glorified pop boy band and then like I said after the drugs they became crazy, weird hippies. What makes the Beatles so good, because they played their own instruments, well so did Creed and we kno what a joke they are and were. Everyone is entitled to their opinion which is fine, but for you hating men to undermine what Mariah has done in her career is just sour grapes and pathetic. I would love to see ELvis or the Beatles survive in this world of music today. We saw how BORING Sir Paul's performance during the halftime super bowl show after nipple gate was, should prove my point.

13. Porfirio T -
Again, I do agree to certain things you've stated. But somehow you seem to think that people who listens to Mariah Carey are all unintelligent, superficial, pretentious bunch. How do you know that Mariah's music have not changed people's lives? Or Whitney Houston, Celine Dione? Are you really that bitter and shallow that maybe, just maybe that their music, yes no matter how homogenous and shallow they maybe that for some that they actually mattered? Do you think you matter?

14. PJ -
Mariah and her music? Excuse me.. She writes???

15. DUDE -
Beam us up Lefsetz!!..There is apparently no intelligent life on Planet Mariah!!!

16. imspidermanontheweb3 -
I have got to say the author is sadly, very accurate. Although this girl is probably the best singer in the pop culture today, she can really belt em out like no other, somehow all her music is boring and forgettable. On American Idol, when they were singing her songs, it was very ho hum. That was suprising to me.

17. imspidermanontheweb3 -
I have got to say the author is sadly, very accurate. Although this girl is probably the best singer in the pop culture today, she can really belt em out like no other, somehow all her music is boring and forgettable. On American Idol, when they were singing her songs, it was very ho hum. That was suprising to me.

18. imspidermanontheweb3 -
I have got to say the author is sadly, very accurate. Although this girl is probably the best singer in the pop culture today, she can really belt em out like no other, somehow all her music is boring and forgettable. On American Idol, when they were singing her songs, it was very ho hum. That was suprising to me.

19. cs g -
I think you're a hater. You hate everything that's popular. I'm no fan of Mariah, but I think she's a talented vocalist and songwriter. You might not like her kind of music, but there's a reason why she has 18 #1 singles. Somewhere out there, people are listening to her music. I listen to Radiohead and Bjork. And my friends tell me that they sound ridiculous. Yes, they do prefer Mariah. But everyone has different taste for music. Just because we do not share similar genre of music, doesn't mean that we should undermine them.
Leave Your Comment
You must sign in to leave a comment
Select a Blog Posts
And The Winner Is...
by Lyndsey Parker
14
As Heard On...
by Suzanne Baran
12
Better Living Through MP3
by Ken Micallef
150
Chart Watch
by Paul Grein
54
Framed
by John Kordosh
60
GetBack
by Cory Frye
89
Hip-Hop Media Training
by Billy Johnson, Jr.
53
List Of The Day
by Rob O'Connor
238
Maximum Performance
by Lyndsey Parker
81
New This Week
by Dave DiMartino
64
On the Road With JamBase
by Aaron Kayce
24
Reality Rocks
by Lyndsey Parker
260
Rock's Backpages
by The Goodfoot Posse
79
Rolling Stone Song Of The Day
by Chuck Eddy
73
Stop The Presses!
by Billy Altman
19
That's Really Week
by Dave DiMartino
68
The ARTHUR Blog
by Paul Krassner
42
The Blender Burner
by Blender Magazine
6
The Lefsetz Letter
by Bob Lefsetz
213
The MOJO Blog
by Stevie Chick
41
The NME Blog
by Dan Martin
22
The Spin Blog
by David Marchese
26
The URB Blog
by Brandon Perkins
9
The Y! Music Playlist Blog
by Robert of the Radish
299
Video Ga Ga
by Lyndsey Parker
40

Music Blog Archives

October 2008 (7)
September 2008 (22)
August 2008 (22)
July 2008 (22)
June 2008 (23)
May 2008 (37)
April 2008 (25)
March 2008 (22)
February 2008 (31)
January 2008 (2)
Even Britney Spears wonders what she was thinking
AP
Fri Oct 10, 2008 1:00pm PDT
AP - If you're wondering what was going through Britney Spears' head during her erratic era, you are not alone — so does she. "I sit there and I look back and I'm like, 'I'm a smart person. What the hell was I…
More »
More Music News
My Music


Create your very own radio station based on your music tastes.