The singer, whose biggest success came during the 1970s and '80s with hits like "You're So Vain" and "Anticipation," is seeking unspecified damages related to the release of the 14-track "This Kind of Love" in April 2008.
In a lawsuit filed Friday with California's Los Angeles County Superior Court, Simon and her attorneys said the album wasn't available in "a substantial number" of Starbucks stores during the key early months following its release. Later, when the disc was stocked in Starbucks locations, the Seattle-based company slashed the price.
"By doing so, Starbucks stigmatized Ms. Simon's album as an album that could not be sold at full price," according to the claim.
In a statement issued Monday, Starbucks said it met all its contractual obligations and even extended the amount of time it promoted the album in New York and Boston.
"Unfortunately, sales continued to lag as the title received tepid response from music consumers," Starbucks said. "Other retailers faced the same fate with this CD."
Simon blamed the performance of the title — which has sold only 124,000 copies, according to The New York Times, which first wrote about the litigation — on a decision by Starbucks days before the album's release to end its involvement in Hear Music, a joint venture with Concord Music.
Simon's next record, "Never Been Gone" is scheduled to be released later this month by Iris Records.
Starbucks shares rose 29 cents, or 1.4 percent, to $20.53 in morning trading Monday.
Carly Simon bounces back with homemade hits album
Nov 2, 2009 1:00 pm PST
Carly Simon rarely performs concerts, due to a toxic combination of stage fright and fear of flying. Fans who really want to hear the singer/songwriter dust off "You're So Vain" or "Anticipation" might be advised to go under the knife...
Carly Simon has "good time" revisiting old songs
Oct 23, 2009 6:00 pm PDT
Carly Simon recorded her new album, "Never Been Gone," at her Martha's Vineyard compound, and she delivers intriguing twists on her hits ("You're So Vain," "Anticipation") and other songs from past albums, as well as two new tunes....
Best-selling book brings back painful memories for Simon
May 12, 2008 8:00 am PDT
Carly Simon didn't find it easy reading "Girls Like Us," the nonfiction best-seller which interweaves her life story with those of fellow singer-songwriters Joni Mitchell and Carole King. Simon was the only one of the three who agreed to ...
Carly Simon charts new course with Brazilian-inspired CD
May 8, 2008 11:00 am PDT
NEW YORK (AP) Carly Simon was worried about preserving her voice as she rehearsed for her first public performance of tunes from her new CD, but she couldn't restrain herself as she got swept away singing the sexy title song, "This ...
Carly Simon to Rachael Ray and friends: You're so vain
May 2, 2008 11:00 am PDT
Surely Carly Simon wasn't talking about anybody in this room. A Rachael Ray fundraiser attended by Bill Clinton, Bobby Flay, Mario Batali, Joy Behar and Katie Lee among others turned into a private concert when Simon took the stage to sin...