Apple, Eminem headed for trial as talks break down

Reuters, Sep 23, 2009 4:00 pm PDT
Apple Inc and Eminem have failed to settle a lawsuit over whether the rapper's songs can be downloaded on the iTunes music service, paving the way for a federal trial to begin on Thursday.

Eight Mile Style LLC, Eminem's music publisher, had accused iPod maker Apple in a 2007 lawsuit of having used 93 songs in a downloadable format on iTunes without permission.

It also sued Aftermath Records, saying it had no right to approve digital downloads, despite having control of Eminem recordings under agreements entered into in 1998 and 2003.

The non-jury trial is expected to be held in federal court in Detroit, Eminem's hometown.

Last-ditch talks held on Wednesday before a federal magistrate judge in Ann Arbor, Michigan, broke down after three different mediators had previously been unable to broker a settlement.

"The case did not settle today and we are expecting to start trial first thing tomorrow morning," Howard Hertz, a lawyer for Eight Mile Style, said on Wednesday.

Apple spokeswoman Susan Lundgren said the Cupertino, California company does not discuss pending litigation. Lawyers for Apple and Aftermath could not immediately be reached.

Another plaintiff in the case is Martin Affiliated LLC, which has a portion of Eight Mile Style's interests.

It is not clear how much money the plaintiffs are trying to recover. They contend Apple wrongfully gained $2.58 million from iTunes downloads, including $466,916 from "Lose Yourself," a hit from Eminem's 2002 film "8 Mile."

The plaintiffs also want part of what they say is Apple's $16 million of profit from iPod sales that could be attributed to the 93 songs, as well as $4.03 million from Aftermath.

Eminem's given name is Marshall Mathers.

In court papers, the plaintiffs contended that Apple "has provided and continues to provide digital downloading of recordings of compositions which Eight Mile and Martin are owners of, or have copyright ownership interest in," without obtaining permission or providing compensation.

In contrast, the defendants have said there was authorization for the downloads and that Eminem's publisher has received "substantial royalties" on the songs.

The plaintiffs expect the trial to last five to seven days. It is not clear whether Eminem would testify, but he is not on the plaintiffs' witness list.

Apple shares closed up $1.02 at $185.50 on Wednesday on the Nasdaq.

The case is Eight Mile Style LLC v. Apple Computer Inc, U.S. District Court, Eastern District of Michigan (Detroit), No. 07-13164.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel, additional reporting by Bernie Woodall in Detroit; editing by Maureen Bavdek and Andre Grenon)

More Artist News

Eminem delays "Relapse 2" but readies "Refill"

Nov 20, 2009 4:00 pm PST

Eminem is pushing his "Relapse 2" album -- originally scheduled for a late 2009 release -- to next year. But in the meantime, on December 21 he'll re-release his fifth studio album with seven bonus tracks as "Relapse: Refill." Accordi...

Eminem says 'Relapse 2' now will come out in 2010

Nov 20, 2009 12:00 pm PST

Eminem's comeback year of 2009 was expected to include the release of two new albums. That turned out to be only partially true. "Relapse," the Detroit rapper's first original studio album in more than four years, debuted at No. 1 on the...

Eminem and 50 Cent to face off on 'Relapse 2' album

Oct 6, 2009 4:00 pm PDT

Courtesy of NME.com -- Em to re-visit 'Guilty Conscience' with Fiddy Eminem and 50 Cent 'face off' on a new song set for Eminem's forthcoming 'Relapse 2' album, the rapper has revealed. Marshall Mathers told his radio station Shade 45 th...

Eminem's music publisher, Apple settle dispute

Oct 2, 2009 8:00 am PDT

Apple Inc. and the music publisher for Eminem have settled a lawsuit over the digital downloading rights to many of the Detroit rapper's songs. Eight Mile Style attorney Richard Busch said Friday that the deal was reached late Thursday. H...

Eminem, Mary J. to pay tribute to Def Jam Records

Sep 2, 2009 4:00 am PDT

Eminem was never a part of Def Jam Records, but the rapper is going to be part of the celebration when the legendary label is honored by VH1. Eminem will join Mary J. Blige, DMX, Public Enemy, Kid Rock, the Roots and more when the label i...

1-6 of 38 videos