The choice of the rapper to perform on the main stage at a festival best known for its guitar-based rock acts was widely criticized, and Oasis's Noel Gallagher riled the musician by saying the organizers were wrong to pick him.
Jay-Z's response was emphatic.
"His performance will go down in Glastonbury history," wrote the Independent in a Monday review of the festival.
Rather than being booed off stage as some predicted, "both audience and artist rose to the occasion and turned in a moment of real, euphoric, pop-culture history," added the Times.
The Guardian concluded: "It's brilliantly staged, utterly thrilling and it makes Gallagher look a bit of a berk."
The Daily Mirror tabloid, however, described his performance as dull.
"I felt seriously short-changed as I walked away from this performance," it said.
WINEHOUSE LESS CONVINCING
While there was plenty of praise for Jay-Z, Britain's soul singer Amy Winehouse was less convincing with what many felt was a shambolic set.
The eagerly anticipated appearance by the 24-year-old shortly after she was diagnosed as having a "touch of" lung condition emphysema failed to live up to the hype, said 19-year-old festival-goer and fan Heidi Cook.
"I saw her last year at Glastonbury and she was out of it but she sang well, but this time she was awful."
Winehouse, sporting her trademark towering black beehive hair, did earn plaudits for turning up in the first place after being a major doubt for Glastonbury.
The singer, who won five Grammys in February, has been fighting drug addiction, was in hospital just before her performance and her husband is expected to be sentenced soon after pleading guilty to attacking a pub landlord in 2006.
Winehouse paid tribute to Blake Fielder-Civil but criticized her father, who announced in a recent newspaper interview that she was suffering from emphysema.
Hundreds of other acts took the stage over the three-day event held on a dairy farm in southwest England, including Gossip and veterans Jimmy Cliff, Neil Diamond and Leonard Cohen.
Organizers struggled to sell all of the tickets to this year's event unlike sellouts of recent years, but Jay-Z and the rest of the cast earned Glastonbury high marks.
"Suddenly, a festival whose very future seemed pretty bleak 24 hours ago feels like a triumph," said the Guardian.
Even the weather complied. Renowned for annual downpours and knee-deep mudbaths, there was more sunshine than rain.
Reuters/Nielsen
The Strokes to make UK festival comeback with Jay-Z
Nov 30, 2009 1:00 pm PST
Courtesy of NME.com -- Headliners for for 2010 Isle Of Wight Festival announced Jay-Z and The Strokes are set to top the bill at next year's Isle Of Wight festival. The rapper will headline on the opening night (June 11), followed by Jul...
Taped beating outside NJ club probed by police
Nov 30, 2009 1:00 pm PST
Police plan to file charges against several bouncers who were videotaped beating two men outside a nightclub co-owned by hip-hop star Jay Z. A video was shot by a disc jockey who had just finished performing early Saturday inside the 40/4...
Jay-Z, Will Smith back Broadway show "Fela!"
Nov 17, 2009 10:00 pm PST
Jay-Z, Will Smith and Jada Pinkett Smith have officially signed on as co-producers of "Fela!," a musical about Nigerian Afrobeat pioneer Fela Anikulapo-Kuti that opens Monday (November 23) on Broadway. The news confirms weeks of speculati...
Rihanna, Jay-Z to perform at American Music Awards
Nov 5, 2009 4:00 pm PST
Rihanna, Eminem, Lady Gaga, Green Day and Carrie Underwood will be among the diverse roster of performers planning to take the stage at the American Music Awards in Los Angeles, show producers said Thursday. Producer Larry Klein said Jay-...
Jay-Z talks World Series, Broadway and DJ Hero
Oct 26, 2009 11:52 am PDT
The New York Yankees have been blasting Jay-Z's "Empire State of Mind" during their playoff run. Now, the team is having the rap king perform the song live to kick off Game 1 of the World Series. Jay-Z and fellow New Yorker Alicia Keys a...