Millions of television viewers were expected to cast telephone and text message votes for feisty, soulful Fantasia Barrino, 19, and bubbly blond Diana DeGarmo, 16, at the conclusion of an often controversial singing contest.
Barrino, a single mother from High Point, North Carolina, and Snellville, Georgia, schoolgirl DeGarmo each sang three songs in Tuesday night's finale.
The three-judge panel had few doubts over their pick for winner after a tearful Barrino brought the audience at Hollywood's Kodak Theater to its feet with renditions of the "Porgy and Bess" classic "Summertime" and a new song "I Believe."
"You're the best contestant we've had in any competition," the normally acerbic British judge Simon Cowell told Barrino.
Record producer Randy Jackson said: "Unbelievable. A master class in singing."
DeGarmo is the youngest contestant to reach an "Idol" final in any of the more than 20 countries worldwide to have adopted the popular format. But her powerful lungs and the brimming confidence of the past few weeks seemed to falter in the final, with some uncharacteristic pitch problems on her last song "Don't Cry Out Loud."
"You had one last chance to nail this competition and I don't think you did," Cowell said.
But the final decision rested with the more than 20 million viewers who have made "American Idol" a mighty ratings hit for Fox TV for the third successive year.
Barrino, who is black, twice narrowly escaped being voted off the show in its latter stages in favor of weaker, cuter singers. That prompted questions over voting procedures and charges of racism -- both of which have been dismissed by producers.
"American Idol" producers extended telephone voting on Tuesday night to four hours from the usual two and added extra phone numbers to counter the logjams and busy signals that have frustrated callers and provoked newspaper headlines over the last few weeks of the competition.
The results will be announced in a two-hour show beginning at 5 p.m. PDT.
Last year's winner, Ruben Studdard, and runner-up, Clay Aiken, secured recording contracts and hit albums.
More than 70,000 "Idol" wannabes auditioned in cities across the United States last summer.
Kelly Clarkson happy with weight, but photo altered
Aug 12, 2009 11:00 am PDT
Singer Kelly Clarkson says she's perfectly happy about her fluctuating weight. So why did Self magazine, in which she made the remarks, retouch its cover photo of the "American Idol" champ to make her look much thinner than she is in r...
'Idol' winner Clarkson is a Susan Boyle fan
May 27, 2009 2:00 am PDT
From one talent show contestant to another: well done. Kelly Clarkson, the winner of the debut season of "American Idol" in 2002, says she's a fan of surprise British singing star Susan Boyle, adding to a growing number of celebrity admir...
A look at 'American Idol' winners
May 20, 2009 9:00 pm PDT
A look at the winners of Fox's "American Idol" and what they've been up to since taking home the prize: • Kelly Clarkson: The 27-year-old singer has released four albums since winning the first "Idol." Her name was immortalized in 2...
"Hannah Montana" album has rival for No. 1 spot
Mar 26, 2009 12:00 pm PDT
Both the "Hannah Montana: The Movie" soundtrack and the "Now 30" compilation are vying for the top slot on next week's U.S. pop album chart. Based on preliminary estimates of their first-day sales on Tuesday, each is on track to sell ...
Look Out, Kelly Clarkson, Rob Pattinson's Crooning Puts Twilight in Chart Spotlight
Mar 25, 2009 11:00 am PDT
The Twilight soundtrack is officially undead—thanks in part to Robert Pattinson's singing debut. The new deluxe version of the soundtrack, timed to the film's weekend DVD release and featuring Count Cullen's first record...