A federal jury in Las Vegas ruled against Stewart Wednesday in a big-bucks dispute between the singer and Harrah's over a scuttled millennium concert.
Stewart must now return a $2 million dollar advance, plus interest, for the nixed Dec. 30, 1999 show, which was to have taken place at the Rio casino-resort on the Vegas Strip.
Jury foreman Stevan Jorgensen told reporters the ruling reflected what jurors thought was simply a contract dispute between Stewart and Harrah's.
"We felt it was only fair," he said, "that if Mr. Stewart didn't perform the concert that he should give the money back."
Stewart, who testified in his defense last week, said he was unable to sing that night because he hadn't fully recovered from a throat operation for thyroid cancer several months prior to the gig.
The British-born rocker and his lawyers said they repeatedly offered to make up the show over the past five years, only to be rebuffed by Harrah's. The casino conglomerate countered that it never would have been able to make as much money for a random concert as it would have made if the "Maggie May" singer headlined a millennium eve show.
Steve Morris, a lawyer for the Rio, told reporters he was "delighted and relieved" with the outcome of the trial; Kerry Garvis Wright, an attorney for Stewart, said the rocker will appeal.
It's the second time in recent months that Stewart has crapped out in court.
Last November, the raspy-voiced rocker was ordered to repay a $780,000 deposit he received for a 2002 Latin American tour that never took place.
The Los Angeles jury in that case also found Stewart liable for an added $1.6 million in punitive damages related to the manner in which his agents and lawyers negotiated the contract for the tour.
Verdicts aside, it hasn't been all bad for the former Faces frontman.
In March, he won his first Grammy, and three months later he announced he is expecting a child with his 34-year-old fiancee, Penny Lancaster. This will be his first child with Lancaster and his seventh overall.
Rod Stewart realizes dream recording with Smokey
Nov 3, 2009 11:00 am PST
Rod Stewart grew up idolizing soul singers like Sam Cooke, Jackie Wilson and Otis Redding. On his new album, "Soulbook," he gets a chance to pay tribute to his childhood idols in song — and even gets a chance to sing with one of them...
Music Review: Rod Stewart bares soul on 'Soulbook'
Oct 26, 2009 12:00 pm PDT
Rod Stewart, "Soulbook" (J Records) Rod Stewart reinvented himself in the new millennium by exercising his distinctly soulful pipes on classic standards with his "Great American Songbook" collection. Now he returns to his soul roots on "S...
Stewart, Flea refute reports of Faces reunion
Jan 22, 2009 6:00 pm PST
Representatives of Rod Stewart and the Red Hot Chili Peppers' Flea have denied reports that the Faces are reuniting after more than 30 years for an album as well as a tour with Flea on bass. Stewart's spokesperson told Billboard t...
Sean Stewart settles case over fight
Nov 20, 2008 2:00 pm PST
A case against Rod Stewart's son over a brawl at a Hollywood nightclub has been resolved. Seal Bral, an attorney for the man who sued Sean Stewart in 2007, says the parties reached a settlement after undergoing private mediation. A Los An...
Rod Stewart plays UK prince's 60th birthday bash
Nov 15, 2008 3:00 pm PST
Singer Rod Stewart headlined a star-studded bash for Prince Charles' birthday party Saturday in England. The pop star known for songs such as "Do Ya Think I'm Sexy" and "Maggie May" performed at a party given by Charles' wif...